legacyme3 : You mean, the 3 players that escaped. Y'know, Knockout, dvk and Chewidment. and I'm assuming they aren't... But if I know Pac... a Plot Twist might be coming up. I also vote Earthwarrior. It seems like He's a CoD fan, so I'm gonna assume that (I always assumed he was a Mother and Earthbound fan 

legacyme3 : Yes, if the murderer wasn't a trusted+ member, I would've notified you guys. So the escapees are considered dead, besides Chewedmint.

earthwarrior :

You are our prime suspect. Have you anything to say in your defense?

legacyme3 : I dunno if we're gonna get a reply... He hasn't been on since January 22nd. Today is the 25th. 3 Day gap.

Sorry for the inactivity. I've been having some trouble getting on my computer. My mom said she's getting me a new one for my birthday .
It's a shame no one knows my favorite game is earthbound. Do you see any pictures of black ops on my profile?
My vote is mrfe.

mrfe : I think you are the only person that likes Call of Duty a lot. I remember multiple times in the chat where you have gone on about the game and how it is a great game and how you are a quick scoper. My guess is you are the second murderer.

Alexanyways' theory was decent but I think earthwarrior's username, profile and what he just said kinda suggests otherwise so you are the only person left that I can think really likes the game.

Do you have anything to say to prove me wrong?

MechaMento :

If I'm not mistaken... mrfe's favorite game is Fire Emblem or one of the Fire Emblem games, is it not? I mean, isn't his username like, based off of it?

I doubt we will find the murderer with this question...

I'm going to cast suspicion on mlb789 (even though he says he prefers Ghosts), MechaMento (Likes FPS games), earthwarrior (because anyone could edit their profile before posting here, I'm keeping an eye on him)

Below is a list of potentially cleared people with reasoning.
Xhero111 - Favorite Game: Pokemon Black - He said this on the first round of questioning when he WASN'T the murderer. And since he had no reason to lie then, we can assume he was telling the truth then.
Frodlex - Favorite Game: BlazBlue - Same reasoning as Xhero, and most of us already knew his preference anyway.
FunnyFurret - Favorite Game: Ace Attorney: Trials and Tribulations. Same reasoning as the two above.
alexanyways - Favorite Game: Metal Gear Solid 3. Again, same reasoning.
a user of this - Favorite Game: Yoshi's Island. Same reasoning.

Anyone not on the above list needs to be considered a prime suspect. Anyone who is on the list above could still be lying, but it is rather unlikely.

The names that are not suspected inherently by me, or in my mind, cleared, are:
Surgiac
mrfe
legacyme3
soxfan849
Seishiro Leonhart
megamanmaniac
supernerd117
Popeye116
FFFighterDill

We should question the people in the above list, as well as those in the suspected list.

For the record, I don't have a "favorite" game, though I guess one could say I'm partial to the MLB the Show series, and games like Rogue Legacy.

FoS: Earthwarrior. and MechaMento

Earthwarrior has voted for mrfe, even though it seems inherently clear that mrfe's favorite series is Fire Emblem, and his favorite game is Fire Emblem. I have seen him playing the game many times on Vizzed. It seems that earthwarrior is backed into a corner, and even though his favorite game has been earthbound in the past, who is to say it is now besides himself?

I no longer feel that I am prepared to vote for earthwarrior just yet, since it seems more likely that mlb or Mecha's favorite game is Call of Duty: Black Ops 2.  But if there should be a plot twist (such as THREE murderers), then it would come to reason that earthwarrior might not want suspicion cast on him, even if he is not the current murderer in question.

Also, Mecha seems to think that mrfe is suspicious.  This casts him under suspicion in my book.

I'm a much bigger fan of the Rainbow 6: Vegas series than I am of any of the Call of Duty games. But like leggy, I'd have a lot of trouble picking a favorite game... I might have to go with Europa Universalis if I *had* to pick one. That or maybe Civ V, but definitely not CoD.

That said, I feel like leaning towards earthwarrior a bit, but his profile is hard to argue against... then again, my layout is from Braid (another excellent game) and my avatar is from Starbound, and I wouldn't call them my favorite games. I just think they look neat.

supernerd117 : ... mrfe knows I like earthbound and he even mods in my earthbound forum, yet he voted for me.
I've played earthbound in the rgr plenty of times before and I submitted screenshots and reviews to earthbound's game page.
I have tons if pictures of earthbound I my profile.
I never wrte a review for a single call of duty game and I've never had a picture of it on my profile.
Leggy you obviously haven't been on my profile in a while. It's been the same for months. I know mecha, xhero, and mrfe have been on it before and most likely remembers.
I change my vote to mlb789 because I know he likes black ops 2 and mrfe seems less likely to be the murderer. (I know he likes FE a lot)

Still not really sure on who I want to vote for but I find earthwarrior & mrfe highly suspicious. Instead of trying to just clear themselves, they're throwing blame at each other.

Does anyone realize that "earth" in my name stands for earthbound?

Surgiac : I'm not throwing blame at anyone, just sharing my suspicions. I apologize if it seems as though I'm attacking earthwarrior. I literally just said "I agree with alex tho, my vote goes for earthwarrior." regarding my vote for earthwarrior. I'm not sure how that comes across as attacking...

I didn't know Mecha had Black Ops 2, so I guess I'll add him to my suspects list. Finding, and eliminating, the murderer needs to be our top priority; let's consider every possibility (which means that, if you feel I'm suspicious, I won't ask you to just drop it. Everyone is entitled to their own suspicions. I just ask that you base accusations off of evidence, and share suspicions so we can catch this guy before he kills more of us.).

mrfe : I misread one of the posts thinking that you had posted it. You're still a suspect though.



mlb said, "Let me put it out there that Ghosts is a much better game than BO2 and my playing time on it justifies it."

This isn't necessarily true. There are games that I've played that have more play time on them than games I like more because that game is short enough for me to play through while waiting for something. Like the Smash Bros. games for example. I just usually have a vs. match or two for 5 minutes each & that usually adds up over time.


EDIT: I'm not sure how relevant this is but I thought it was an interesting post to consider:

https://www.vizzed.com/boards/thread.php?id=52320&ppp=20&page=0#715274

My vote is for MechaMento.  Even though mlb789 has stated that his favorite game is one in the CoD series, I think MechaMento has been playing the long game since he is the murderer.  Let's give this a shot (pun intended), and take him down!

According to alex, "I really enjoyed the original Black Ops and this one [Black Ops 2] is a brilliant addition to that."

I don't know about anyone else, but I think that contradicts the earlier statement when he said "Black Ops 2 is my least favorite Call of Duty by far. Black Ops 1 was fun to an extent but 2 was pretty bad. I can't imagine anybody outside of the filthy casual world calling it their favorite game."

He's not necessarily the person who I think is the killer, since he probably does like BO1 moire than BO2, but now I am suspicious of him.

Hey, it got harder?

We really shouldn't pull out super sayan mode suspicions on anyone. Who knows, there could be this super sneaky person in our middle. Let's look at evidence.

- The user likes black ops 2
-For that, he (or surgiac), following semi legal rule thingies, should be around 15-16 or higher.
-Looking at the words the murderer used, we can somewhat assume he was 'against' the question, as he commented somedisagreeing words on it.
*mrfe first was somewhat negative about it, though he changed his mind.
*surgiac kind of was against it at first.
*supernerd117 was against it.

megamanmaniac : That's interesting.

Megaman's earlier post were indeed my words, however, I was caught up in release hype at that point, seeing as how I just bought the game. After about a week I stopped playing and realized that it's quite easily the worst. And a year after that, it shouldn't count as a contradiction, more of an aged opinion.

Plus, it has been known that MGS3 was my favorite game, and that remains.

I would like to address earthwarrior's skiddishness and overreacting, if you were any amount of innocent, you wouldn't freak out like that.

I'll vote earthwarrior. He's really acting suspicious & defensive and while yes, the earth in his name may stand for Earthbound, the warrior in his name could still stand for CoD: BOII. I view soldiers to be warriors of a sort.