Well, yeah I do think they should remake Pokémon yellow but they already made so many remakes of crystal.

Yeah sure, why not?

They've already remade pretty much every other Pokémon game out there... and they keep on creating more Pokémon, so why not.

Just go all out, creating as much Pokémon as possible until we finally become surrounded by Pokémon being everywhere.

I don't really think they should. It's some old games that i think it's best to leave alone. I love pokemon yellow and it was my first pokemon game ever. I Don't want them to mess with that.

Well it's a good idea... but there is already a remake of Blue, Red, Gold and Silver...
Yellow and Crystal they're almost the same as Blue, Red, Gold and Silver!
I think it's better that there is first a Remake of Ruby and Sapphire!

I think they should leave it how it is because the game play for me is cool and original.....maybe not sure....

I am 50-50 on this, maybe they should because with all of the new technology it would look really nice with the graphics and all, but then again crystal is already the same as heartgold and soulsilver so I guess that wouldn't really make any sense. I think it would be really cool if they did remake all of those games but I don't think they should really add or change any of the actually gameplay, content or Pokémon in the game because it is awesome the way it is and it shouldn't be changed but I can guarantee if they decided to they would probably load the game up with extra stuff and the game will probably end up nothing like the original Pokémon yellow because everything is all changed. So I would just say for them to change the graphics and make it look nice but keep the original storyline and gameplay all the same or else it would just be pointless.

I've been wanting a Pokemon Yellow remake for the longest time now. I just think it would be amazing. Pokemon Yellow is by far my favorite, and all I want them to do is remake it with better graphics and a little minor changes here and there, nothing major. As for pokemon Crystal, that would be pretty cool as well. Crystal is my second favorite pokmeon game of all time, I wish they would consider this though.

Well if you had not noticed, Heart-Gold and Soul-Silver had some of the aspects of Crystal in them so a full remake is very unnecessary.
As for Yellow, It was based on Ash at the time and Ash has come so far from then, newer fans wouldn't understand half the game whilst
older fans would maybe enjoy the nostalgia. However fans may demand more than what original game had giving Game-freak a hard time.
Not to mention if you look at this from Game-Freak's perspective, what would you make more money from? A single " sister " game or two
games they can split Pokémon between, the answer would be two games as this would make more money and be a smarter business
move. Okay yes I wouldn't mind a remake or two, but not of these particular games, I would rather have a remake of Emerald as I miss
the original Battle Frontier as I found it much more challenging and fun compared to the Battle Frontier introduced for the fourth generation.

All in all I would not say that remaking these games would be good, they certainly wouldn't be too bad. I mean they were fun, although a bit
outdated by the standards of today's gaming market. It would also offer a fresh alternative to the old games with the more limited graphics
and would allow you to fully enjoy the game for what it was but in much better quality, this would probably make the game more immersing
and altogether just as enjoyable, the thing is though, with the majority of remakes we have seen, there has always been additional things
added to the game, this may ruin the feeling for some, and what I meant by that was, in the first remake games, Leaf Green and Fire Red
the Sevii Isles were added to add more to the after-game experience, this also changed how one would catch certain Pokémon such as
the legendary birds, Articuno, Zaptos and Moltres. Additions were also added to Heart-Gold and Soul-Silver which actually improved the
experience, such as your Pokémon being out and following you, Gold leafs ( Read it up if you don't know what they are, ) heck even the
Battle frontier from Sinnoh was added, however certain things were changed making the game a bit different from before, such as the
Safari being in a new location, this may have made someone slightly confused on how to progress.

Overall I would say some of the games would be okay to have remakes * crosses fingers for Hoenn Saga. * but only if they kept the
original glory of the game in-tack. I would not say I hated remakes but I would not say I loved them either.

Yes I do because I for one loved Pokemon Yellow mainly because I could get all the Kanto starters and it truly was the Ash Ketchem  story to the T.

They should. Getting every starter without wasting all your money and poke balls.

Yeah, it would be nice. The third installments are pretty much always better, and it would be nice to see them remade, especially Yellow. But what would be best is if they made a real Ash Grey, where you follow Ash through his adventure. I would definitely buy that. And a new Emerald would be much better than a Ruby/ Sapphire remake.

Well they remade red green gold and silver so why not .

I don't think so. They already got so many remakes as it is. Why keep adding, and adding. By then they would have 6 johto games that didn't need to be there, but I do think they should have remade yellow. That is all.

Yes I do think they should make remakes of Pokémon Yellow and Pokémon Crystal!

Yes, yes I do I loved those to game my first one was crystal.