I never said I'd "off" him. I just merely implied I'd be watching him more closely.

What is your favorite sport thread

megamanmaniac says basketball. I have no reason to doubt him, I know he loves the Celtics.

I said baseball, and that's a fact. Anyone who knows me knows I love the Red Sox more than life itself.

MechaMento says it's soccer, so for now he's off the hook (though he says he likes FPS games, so we can't say he's cleared)

----

I'm also not ready to clear the following names - Surgiac, alexanyways, FFFighterDill, and a user of this.

They have all posted since the murderer announced he liked Hockey, and so far, I haven't found any evidence to the contrary. Anyone can say anything in this thread, and I don't trust any of those 4.

I'm still leaning to mrfe however, as he simply makes too much sense at the moment.

I'm also going to take this moment to say I'm almost positive mlb789 and soxfan849 are cleared, since I know the former almost definitely prefers baseball to hockey (given his username), and while soxfan849 likes hockey, based on conversations with him, he is "probably" more into football than anything else.

One more note we should keep in mind, though it's doubtful and depends entirely on what pacman would "allow" the murderer to say... it's entirely possible the murderer doesn't like sports at all, and just chose hockey because it is his/her "favorite" of the few they are aware of.

Just something to keep in mind.

I still am not sure what this is or why I am a part of it, but ok.

Surgiac : It was what I like to call, a joke. You see, tgags is a big hockey fan. So since the murderer says he likes hockey, I was jokingly accusing him.

A user of this :

Joking or not, you have to look at it in a serious light.

It looks like you are deflecting, even as a joke.

We have to take it seriously, and now you are a suspect.

I can't believe how opposite I am from the killer. I mean, come on. SOMEONE has to have the same interests as I do.

Anywho, we know that the killer loves BO2 and hockey. We need to focus on finding out who enjoys both instead of looking at who likes one and then who likes the other. Right now, I'm most suspicious of Mrfe. It seems as if he's trying to avoid directly saying that hockey is his least favorite sport. All I hear is that he hasn't watched it in a few months, but all that means is that you aren't caught up with the sport. That doesn't mean that it is not (or was not) your favorite sport. Furthermore, just because you watch one sport over the other, it doesn't mean that you like the sort more. You could watch every week of the regular season in football and watch only one hockey game, and enjoy the hockey game more than any of the football game. Unless I hear you say that hockey is not your favorite sport, I am going to suspect you as the killer, especially since you do play BO2 as well.

I don't necessarily suspect a user of this because ridiculous comments like that one were bound to happen at some point. Although he may be trying to randomly involve tgags123 in this whole thing, I don't think that he's a suspect (at least not because of his joke).

megamanmaniac : That was what i was thinking, every clue points to the murderer so we cant focus on just ONE clue we have to look for someone who connects to the clues, however "shallow" they may be.


I honestly could not tell you one hockey player at all, most i can remeber is some football teams, KU,K-State, seahawks,Broncos, Green Bay.


and Mega, your in the same boat as me, there is nothing in there with the same intrerests as me. (unless there was a pokemon one, then that one i liked. I honestly cant remeber if there was one.

"FunnyFurret: I suspect merf"

Looks like I might be right after all. Though I'm not quite sure just yet. We almost know your name, Kringle, watch out.

FunnyFurret :

It's about as likely as you being the murderer

Take that how you will.

One thing to note is he's adamantly claimed that Fire Emblem is his favorite, while it's possible he really does like Black Ops 2 more, it's also possible this is a pointless kill on our part.

-----

I also have to wonder if the Murderer has even posted in this thread. We have a few people not even attempting to help one way or the other.

legacyme3 : I know good enough that the more suspicion I give you because of that claim the more suspicious I will become to perhaps you and some others. I'm not THAT stupid.

I guess I'd put merf's suspicion meter at 7/10, a little above average. Not enough to provide judgement in any way. I also love how people think user is suspicious when all he did was a little joke.

FunnyFurret :

It's silly, but you have to suspect someone for making a joke like that at the same time.

If you don't, you are giving license to the murderer to get away with joking like that to deflect suspicion.

Think of it like this. If a user of this is the murderer, you just gave him a greenlight, and almost all suspicion on him is dropped. Rather than ignore it and set bad precedent, we allow ourselves to focus on the serious nature of the game (finding the murderer).

Also yes, suspecting me would lead to heavy suspicion on your part, given how much I detest the two things the murderer likes

legacyme3 : For now, I do believe you don't like the things the murderer does but there is also the possibility that you are the mastermind behind all of this a la Mafia.


On a side note.....

I saw ZEBRA LEGGY on this page before I started posting!

I honestly don't have a favorite sport, but I must reinterate that CoD'BO2 is not going to suddenly be my favorite game if hockey was my favorite sport. These two need to go hand in hand because the killer didn't get found after the last question. Same person, therefore he needs to enjoy Black Ops II and Hockey both.

-------------------

Legacy certainly is putting a large amount of effort to his posts, but that's who he is. He's clear in my mind because it was always very apparent to me that these two things were not close to things he'd remotely enjoy.

-------------------

Murphy may be named for Fire Emblem, but he didnt say outright that it was absolutely his favorite game.

His account was made a few months before the release of BO2, and he could have changed his mind when it came out or later on.

He also used to collect hockey cards, and is now selling them. It could very well be possible that he doesnt care for hockey as much as he did then, but he did enough to be considered a big fan in the past.

It's possible he no longer likes sports, and given the question, should he be the killer, he wouldnt have an answer other than Hockey due to it being his favorite sport in the past.

For these reasons, I'm setting my vote on mrfe.

Alright, I noticed day 7. and remember what Pac said first? "Want Christmas to extend to another week? Ho Ho Ho! You found the right place! Stop on by Kris Kringle's Christmas Mansion, and have a Jolly ol' time! Candies! Presents! Secret Santas! and much much more! Stop on by on the address below along with the date it begins..." "Want Christmas to extend to another week?" If you all have gotten right to the point, you noticed that the end of the week is Day 7, and guess what day it is. Does this mean that the madness will be over, or is there some kind of catch?

FYI, Popeye116 quit the game.

My guess is there's some kind of catch. I'm not exactly sure if a murderer would honor their word.

I don't know when the deadline to choose someone is but I'm voting for Mrfe, since all of the evidence up to his point seems to point to him.

The update will happen in 2 days, Saturday. Make sure you pick your vote.

Keeping my vote on mrfe for now, it may be wrong, but we have no leads right now.