Sonic. He has all the speed on his side. 

Sonic ! Sonic is fast, can transform in Super/Hyper Sonic...

Whilst Sonic does have a speed advantage over the red Echidna ( That is Knuckles ) .. he can't fly in his normal form . Knuckles can . But I guess Sonic natural speed is still an advantage . But Knuckles does have a strength over Sonic . But it would be useless if you can't catch him . Knuckles would get tired easily and then Sonic would just strike and beat him . 

Awesome-Kid : have you watched sonic x sonic owns knuckles 

Galacta : There is a chance that could happen, but at last there is some gaping holes. I mean sure sonic could get cornered, and knuckles could knock him out, but Obviously Knuckles himself is way too stupid to realize that, and Even if sonic was in a corner he could easily use his speed to get out.


sonic23 :




Yeah I saw that. Knuckles Just doesn't time it right, and at the end it cause's him the fight.


Eniitan :

IgorBird122 :   Yes, but Knuckles is way too slow, to even get a hit, If you watch sonic X. Knuckles couldn't even hit Sonic once, I mean sure there's a possiblty of being powerful, but if your slow, and someone's faster than you. That's gonna manually put you at a disavantage. Not to mention, since Sonic is the main star of sega, It's highly unlikely they would make him lose Imo.


There are the chances of Sonic becoming his super fourm, and being the crud out of knuckles.,

But at the end: If Shadow was there, He'd Own both of them XD. But Since this poll is only for sonic vs Knuckles, I'll put my money on sonic. His speed is just too much for Knuckles.

Knuckles could only win if he held down Sonic and punched him in the face enough to make him die, but that would be impossible with a brain like Knuckles' brain. Sonic could always use his speed to get away if Knuckles ever got too close.

Well while Knuckles undoubtedly has more physical strength, Sonic is much faster. I think Sonic would take it as Knuckles simply wouldn't be able to keep up with his speed and even if Knuckles was winning Sonic could easily escape.

Although Sonic is my favorite video game character of all time, i believe Knuckles will win because of his strength. Sonic has the speed, but Knuckles has the strength. Sonic could easily escape, but Knuckles could find him, and punch him.

MaijjikalMotart : Don't think so because can run so far that he would never reach him and even if he did Sonic could easily run away again without even breaking a sweat. And I still think Sonic would win because knuckles wouldn't be able to counter his blows because they're so fast meanwhile Sonic could easily evade his.

pacman1755 (old) : I choose Sonic, because his speed is that fast, that Knuckles won't be able to land a single hit on Sonic. Then, BAM, Sonic will quick attack him and beat him up :3, Knuckles won't be able to catch him up.

I think this is no contest, Sonic would win. In terms of the comics anyway. In the games I think it would be very close, but sonic would still win. Especially with his super sonic form!