Hey guys so with valentines day this Friday I plan on doing something special for my valentine so I plan on going into her class during 5th or 6th period and sing a love song to her but the only thing is would it be a good idea because right now I'm really nervous so what do you guys think should I do it or not now if I get in trouble hell I could care less   

Who cares about the trouble you might be in. What you SHOULD ask yourself is do you think she will be embarrassed if you did that. Would it be romantic, or just awkward. So depending on how well you know her, you can make your choice. I know some girls get embarrassed with stuff like that, and not in the good way.

You have to think of this from her point of view.  The guy above me has the right call: What will her reaction be?  She might be embarrassed and get mad at you for pulling a stunt.  You also do have to think about how much song you can get out in the class before it gets ended.

Good idea but it might be bad execution.

sonic23 : Dude its okay if you go with your first guess. Never take advice from other people over yourself even if the odds are against your favor. I personally think you should do this, and it would be a little corny but still at least she would know that you love her, buts that's only if you really do. Hope my advice helped you to boost up your confidence though. Just doing what I can to help .

Good idea or not? Well......

I would not do it. But if you do, you are very, very brave.

I don't think it's a very good idea to do it during her class.  Many girls would be embarrassed or disappointed by that sort of thing.  There is a time and place to do that sort of thing, and it's not during her class.  True love involves sacrifice, but obedience is greater than sacrifice.  Even bad girls are impressed when you stay within the rules, but not if you're self-righteous.  Don't overdo it, of course.  The rules are supposed to help you with this sort of thing, and rules are never imposing, unless people use them falsely.

Well anyways, she'll be impressed if you write her something cool and heartfelt, but she'll be able to sense if you really don't mean them.  Make sure every word you speak to her is the truth.  That's what true love is about.  But be careful.  Getting too involved with a girl this early in life may lead to a path you aren't ready for (or she isn't ready for, or both).  Instead of overdoing it, just do something to show you care.  Doing too much will probably creep her out or overwhelm her.  You've got this, bro.  Show her your mad skills.  If she laughs at you, then find a girl that will appreciate you for who you are.  She may wish you to change in certain ways, but make sure that girl does not want you to deny yourself of what's important.  A good girl will care for you despite your faults, even if she does not approve of some of your choices.  Find that girl, and treat her well, and she will treat you well back, and you both will have an awesome relationship.

Out of curiosity, what's your relationship with her? You said valentines, but... is she your girlfriend?

I mean, if you guys are boyfriend and girlfriend, then you should definitely go for it. It would be considered romantic. However, if you do this and you guys aren't going out yet, that would cause a bit of stress. Especially for her.

Serenading her during class... in front of 20ish other people... and probably a good number of them would be girls? I sense potential disaster. If you guys aren't even boyfriend and girlfriend, that is.

Sorry to be on such a depressing side here, but it's better to be safe than sorry. Especially since it's going to affect her, too.

If you get in trouble with her though, you won't like it...
As many have already pointed out, you should also consider if she'll like what you're planning to do. Many girls love having their partners show how much they love them publicly through serenading, giving presents or doing any other surprises, but not all the time and certainly not everywhere.

I for one dislikes class interruptions by other students or by people not belonging in our class. I don't appreciate student councils barging in, students who forget their stuff inside our room and coming in to get it in the middle of class, and candy vendors who visit every room during the last months of school years. How much more if it was caused by someone I really know and he interrupted the class because of me? I'd definitely prefer it if it's done after class instead.

I would say not in the class. That will get you in trouble with the teacher, her in trouble with the teacher, embarrass her in front of her class mates.  It's not a good situation.

What you should do is do it during lunch, before school starts, or after school gets out.  When I was in 12th grade my boy friend came to me at lunch with a home made boxed lunch and slipped a lunar pendant around my neck~!  Ooooo boy!  That was sooo romantic also a nice peck on the cheek!  I felt like the queen of the world then!  If you can't do it during lunch then do it at the other times I mentioned.

I guess I would say weigh your options. Are you so nervous do you think you will sing bad? are you normally an outspoken person? If you have the confidence I'd say go for it, if not.., use a more subtle approach

Valentine's Day is like, way over already, lol. So I'll go ahead and close this thread.