What's the creepiest video game creepypasta? Legend of Zelda MM has a TON of them. And I mean a TON. For me...it's a tie with Sonic.exe and Ben Drowned. I haven't heard the story of Sonic.exe but the picture is creepy. However with Ben, he doesn't look so bad. He just looks like an ordinary Kokiri boy. But the story is that somebody found a figure in their copy of Legend of Zelda MM, and Ben would spawn at dark areas or areas where there are no NPC's and do weird things to your character. Scary music plays, he can burn you, he can make you float, and before you start the game, the file name would be "You're Next" or "Ben drowned." I wish I had Ben in my copy of the game.

I have to say the lost silver just crept me out a bit Sonic exe seemed even more creepier. Those were the only creepypasta videos I actually saw (I've never saw the Ben video though).

I remember seeing a thread like this before. Anyways, I would say Sonic.exe. I have actually even played it before since someone made a game of it. Dang, its very creepy. Sonic.exe's eyes are just... OMG. XD

I am into all of this creepypasta stuff but the majority of it is not that scary at all. The Sonic.EXE pasta is in my opinion a bad pasta. Yes the "I Am God" did creep me out but as a creepypasta itself it is just full of cliche. Other pastas like MARIO and the Pokemon Black are just not creepy at all. Pokemon Black, you have a ghost, now how it that scary? Look I am going to stop complaining about bad creepypastas and mention the great ones. 
The pasta that made me feel scared was the BEN Drowned creepypasta. You all knew it was coming, didn't you. It may not be the best written pasta since it is jam packed with cliche but the fact that it has a video to assist it really makes it believable. I think it is the random screams, like when he played the ocarina, the lovely song played and then.... AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA. Well headphone users were dead!

B619ook : You said you had never watched the BEN Drowned videos, so here you go...









By the way, that is the order they go in

I have not read one but the Lavender Town Trauma music seems sort of creepy to me. Too high pitched. Gives you a headache and all that kind of stuff. So Lavender town wins by default. Or the Buried Alive is weird too.