The reason I gave it a 9.5 in graphics is because it has a few very minor graphical glitches other than that it works perfect.

I gave it a 10 for sound because it had good sound for when it was made with a few other games that where made in that time on this system you would have a few sound errors this is the only one so far that has no error that I can hear.

I gave it a 10 for addictiveness because I can play this for what seems like a minute and look up and realize that several hours have passed on top of that it has many different stories that you can playthrough but more on that soon.

I gave it a 10 on depth because it lets you choose how to play you get to choose your characters you get to choose there stats you get to even choose there future classes (to a degree)

I gave it a 2 in difficulty but that is because I have played secret of mana in the past and they have very similar play styles and that let me know the controls ahead of time if I had not played secret of mana I would have likely made it a 6 with a bit of a learning curve.

Now for story I gave it a 10 this one is last because if it was out of 100 this would be the only perfect score the reason for this is that it remains consistent across games where one characters story is always the same and based on who you choose it tells a whole new story.
One of the few problems with this is that the players that did not speak or read Japanese lost a lot in this game before the translation as Lumian
said in there review.

I give this game a 9 out of 10 The reason I did not quite rate it 10 is because there are a few problems with it for example sometimes you hit an enemy where in the same conditions sometimes you don't as well as dexterity and luck being all broken from what I can see they only help with one thing they do is help with chests a lot less then they are meant to.

This isn't exactly what you would call a review. You may want to put more detail in what you say, and give more explanations as to why you think this game deserves a 4.5 or the ratings of your other categories. Remember, reviews need to be at least 300 words (I think) to count as a review.

play4fun : This always happens with newbies... to be honest I think they should be given an example before letting them make a review.

iN008 : Maybe someone should develop something like that. It think that would be a good idea to put a link on the review submission page to show what the site is actually expecting for a review.

Reviews must be at least 100 words. And yes, giving more detail as to why you rated it what you did in each category would be a good way to lengthen it. Try that next time.

I will be trashing this one, but don't be discouraged. Give it another go.

Well... we shouldn't all be so critical towards a newbie...

Soraroxasxion : Try and accept all the feedback we have given