I'm not really gonna be active that much since I have to do my job and stuff

kabenon007 : Town tree or Mafia tree, it's still MasterDash. <_>

Also, interesting to say, starwars. Now let's see if the other quiet ones are going to talk. Or if accusations are going to start flying. Does anyone else, perhaps, have any leanings or hunches based on who was targeted?

Oh, I'm not quiet at all.

I think you'll find me willing to talk more when we're talking about actual gameplay rather than tentacle monsters. Which hey, we appear to be doing at the moment.

Not exactly sure how you think I'm quiet though, or can even tell if I am or not considering the actual discussion has only just started. Admittedly I can't contribute much at the moment as I'm not sure what to expect... But inversely, you don't know what to expect from me. Don't assume I'll be quiet all game however.

You want to get the ball rolling? I'll vote starwars293. You say he's unusually quiet, he says he isn't active. Maybe true, maybe not. But seems he's the least risky kill.

i vote masterdash maybe if we keep trying leg will have mercy

(no kill)

Vote: drag00n365

Voting no kill, especially day one, is a bad idea. It offers up little to no discussion and then we have very little information in hand going into the next day, and then the Mafia get a free kill. Feel free to defend yourself.

kabenon007 : You aren't very experienced in this, are you?

An early-game No Kill is usually harmless, especially if there's little info to go by, and it's impossible to lynch the one person we'd -want- to lynch. You also have to consider that it may be better to let the night roles do their part, rather than lynching wildly and hitting a Town-sided Loose Cannon, a Doctor, or a Town Sheriff. It's perfectly understandable for the early game to lean towards it until something outlandish happens. It's riskier to No-Kill in the end game where you may possibly have a "Lynch or Lose" scenario.
I'll also remind you that sonicmcmuffin also voted No Kill. Are you ignoring him? If so, for any particular reason?

If you're going to accuse drag00n, think of a better reason. Otherwise I suggest you change your vote.

kabenon007 : that accusation was almost as stupid as master dash and just as pointless

Ok. So, let's say that we don't kill anyone, everyone just votes no kill and the day passes in one page. The mafia then gets to kill for free, with no threat to them at all from the day work we have done as no one has had to accuse nor defend themselves. Then we have no data to go on day 2 because no discussion has taken place. The best weapon we have is the interaction between players, and if everyone just jumps to no kill as the automatic day 1 option, there is no discussion, therefore we waste our best weapon.

So perhaps I should rephrase: simply voting no kill without a strong reason to do so is silly, as it is detrimental to the innocent bystanders. It is, however, useful if we do have a lot of information gathered because of it. That is more what I meant.

kabenon007 : if we kill somebody off on the first day round without info its even more harmful because chances are we will lynch a good guy not to mention voting for somebody now doesnt stop the mafia from killing tonight its an uneccisary risk.

kabenon007 : Your logic still has one big, massive hole; When no info is there to go on, lynching blindly is a terrible idea, and THAT gives the Mafia a free kill.

You also completely ignored what I said about sonicmcmuffin. Kind of ironic considering your paragraph about player interaction.

I'd consider voting against you based on this unintelligent insistence, but... you don't seem stupid from how you're typing. Are you, perhaps, a second Fool? Wouldn't put it past Leggy to add a second one, after all.
Or are you Mafia, pretending to be the Fool? I personally just hope you're out of the game by the next day round.

If you can't think of a better reason to accuse drag00n, change your vote.

MasterDash : To be honest, I was trying to give you negative Viz. I now know that doesn't work.

I don't really have anything to add to the discussion, so I'll agree with Kiddo and vote No Kill.

kabenon007 : Alright, a few games ago I think I'd agree with you. However, a few very bad mis-lynches have since changed my mind. It's kind of frustrating killing off a doctor in a day round. I agree with Kiddo here, we should wait for more info.

... That being said, there's almost enough for an FoS or two already, but not enough for me to vote. I don't want to miss again, I remember starting the wagon train on the wrong guy last time. That was... bad. At least I got the GF that round.

Settling on the no-kill bandwagon, myself. There's a high enough body count in the night round as it is, anyway.

[12:16 PM] big fat cat: why did i even sign up
[12:16 PM] big fat cat: for mafia
[12:16 PM] WarpStarFerret: *Shrugs*
[12:16 PM] WarpStarFerret: Because it's awesome.
[12:16 PM] big fat cat: this is all your fault ermine
[12:17 PM] big fat cat: i wish an hero was an option
[12:17 PM] big fat cat: i just want to listen to my 8bit goodness all day without mafya


........... :/ Dead role is dead. Should we deal with it now or later? Of course, he could be a Fool, but I don't think he is personally. I have no idea what role he is, but if he won't contribute... :| Should we lynch or leave it be for now?



[12:31 PM] big fat cat: I am all godfather

Okay, my first thought is sarcasm. This still smells like sarcasm while looking at it, but then I stop and think SNOWDEATH.

leggy--is that claim check able by a researcher? It should be helpful if it is.

[12:35 PM] WarpStarFerret: [12:31 PM] big fat cat: I am all godfather
[12:35 PM] WarpStarFerret: Is that claim checkable?
[12:35 PM] WarpStarFerret: leggy
[12:36 PM] legacyme3: warp - only by a researcher
[12:36 PM] WarpStarFerret: That's all I wanted to know, thanks

It's claim check-able. If there's a researcher out there, it's your choice what to do with this. It could give us a little info, or even a lot of info based on the results.

If bfc is giving up -and- he's Godfather, then that's just... pretty sad to happen.

I'm assuming Leggy has a backup plan for a situation like this, if it turns out.

KiddoCabbuses :

I don't need a plan for this type of thing.

I'm pretty confident it'll work itself out.

WarpStarFerret : There's that something called school and sleep. Yeah, I can't vote on command like most people.

So the "fool" Fallman dies, Sept dies and he's the Forger. Whoever that is. I think that's the second Mafia he's been in and the second time he died right away. Damn. Alex dies and he's the Doctor. Well, we're in trouble now. And MasterDash is....a tree. I guess his "Insanity" so to speak, will have to survive through in this round.

There isn't any clear idea who the mafia is, even though there HAS been a long..long..night round, I'll no kill

BREAKING NEWS

A RESEARCHER HAS CHECKED BIG FAT CAT FOR GODFATHER

BIG FAT CAT IS NOT THE GODFATHER.

OOOOHHHH

Nice waste of a Researcher check. That thing Snow pulled could only ever work once. I'm pretty sure Diem was just being Diem and dickin' around.

Honestly, we have enough people that a lynch isn't a terrible idea. Yes, it's risky, but it could pay off big. And it's not like this is a MyLo situation.

I just don't really see anyone worth the risk of lynching. The immediate NL from sonic is kind of bothering me. Don't even wait to see what discussion brings up, or if any cops find Maf.

FoS : sonicmcmuffin

The only reason I don't say anything about drag is because of that entire thing with kabenon and yeah.

So BFC lied.... but what's the point of that? Seemingly just to out the presence of a Researcher. Figures.
Is he Mafia trying to gather intel, or Fool causing chaos? I don't think a Town guy would have done that, regardless - it was simply a trollish move designed to hinder them.
FoS on BFC.
no-kill is still my vote, though.