Well I should've put this thread on favorites earlier... I always miss a bunch until pac posts...

So everyone's on board with sports then?

I really don't think that the question would work, I think it'll be the too specific thing again. I'll vote for it, cause most everyone else already voted. 

Vote: "What's your favorite sport?"

Yeah, that question works for me. Not much else to say.

I guess favorite sport would be okay but I'm not sure it will reveal much whether it's specific or not.

Huh. That was pretty easy.

Okay guys, since it has gotten over the majority, I will ask the murderer the question "What is your favorite sport?"

Majority vote wins in a matter of 1 day.

EARLY UPDATE

The murderer has spoken and the murderer says

My Favorite sport is football

Now discuss between yourselves who the murderer might be! You have 1 week to decide.

LIST O' PLAYERS
legacyme3 :
Gamin'Gal :
Popeye116 :
sonicmcmuffin :
megamanmaniac :
zanderlex :
earthwarrior :
mvhupsel :
Barathemos :
deg2000 :
Zlinqx :
kirbmanboggle :
patar4097 :
Mecha Leo :
Surgiac :
thing1 :
Blubcreator :
mlb789 :
Frodlex :
darthyoda :

This is a tough one, I can only name one user who likes football a lot and that's thing1, but I don't actually know much about what other users like.

zanderlex :

The thing is, the murderer didn't specify whether it was American Football or European Football (soccer for everyone in the US).

As a result, while thing1 looks bad, you can't take your eyes off anyone from outside of the United States/Canada.

In fact, I'm going to put an FoS on sonicmcmuffin, as well as thing1.

Sonicmcmuffin is a suspect because I do believe he has used the server before (he doesn't have the game in his collection list, but you don't NEED to be on the collection list to use the server), he roughly fits the activity guideline of 6/10, and as far as I know, he still loves European Football.

If we do not get a confirmation as to what brand of football the murderer is referring to, then we have to proceed under the possibility that the murderer likes soccer, and calls it football.

EDIT - Actually, in that vein, anybody who likes soccer is also a suspect, because there are Americans who call it football as well. So proceed with that knowledge.

legacye3: Still, its not like everyone just asks each other what their favorite sport is. All I know about thing1 is that he liked football, but the majority of users would probably only guess that he just likes it and not if its his favorite. If it is soccer, then sonicmcmuffin is indeed the biggest suspect for that. The hard part is not finding out if someone likes football, but if its their favorite, like I would immidiatly scratch you off.

legacyme3 : Nice to see someone is using some logic, Sadly it isn't me... You know full well that i play dodgeball and talk about it a lot more than football. Plus I know this is a really minor detail that no-one will pick up on... But i believe the murderer is American due to the way the answers have all been spelt, If that makes sense. Also i'm less active than you on the site.. So i feel a 6 would be far too optimistic and honestly it's pretty against my personality... 

I'm glad that other people besides myself has not crossed anyone off the suspects list though... Literally anyone could have logged into the minecraft server once.. and their answer would be yes. It's a pretty mediocre question in that aspect.. There's still a lot of people it could be. 

However someone i do think fits the agenda is blubcreator.. He's been silent pretty much, Especially since thing1 started accusing everyone so FoS Blubcreator

sonicmcmuffin :

Yeah, I know you speak about Dodgeball a lot, but while it's your favorite to play, as far as I know, I can't guarantee to other people that you like it more than a sport that your country is stereotypically obsessed with (Sorry about that )

I also am intrigued to hear what Blubcreator has to say for himself.

For the moment, I will abstain from a proper vote until we have a little more talk from the other players. No point rushing in and killing an innocent person.

legacyme3 : It's not me. I've never been on the Vizzed Minecraft server, so it can't be me. I've been waiting to get a new laptop to get Minecraft to be able to get on the Vizzed Minecraft server. 

I would like to place a FoS Barathemos. He's been on the Vizzed Minecraft server & from what I can tell, he seems to have about a 6/10 in activity. He's also posted in the Football section of the sports forum & favors the Seahawks to win the Superbowl. Not that the favoring part has anything to do with it but it shows he at least holds an interest in the sport.

Surgiac : just to rest your case, I got minecraft yesterday and the question was asked on 1/10.

Not trying to defend myself, just trying to narrow down the suspects.

Mlb789 loves football. I haven't been on the minecraft server enough to see him, too bad EM is dead. And he isn't too active, but yet somewhat active.

As far as the answers go they all to pertain to me somehow.

I have logged on to the vizzed server once or twice for a little bit and my favourite sport is football if we are referring to the European sport.

It'd be daft to try and defend myself against facts however the only one that doesn't really fit my category is the 6/10 activity wise. I would probably rate myself more of a 4/10 as of late. Back when the question was asked I would've easily rated myself a 3/10.

As for actually finding the murderer if we are acknowledging the theory that he meant football as in soccer then I thought it's be wise to check my old FIFA thread. I would assume if it was their favourite sport they would've posted there at least once. However none of the names really helped. The only people who posted from this game (that are still alive obviously) are:

zanderlex
legacyme3
Mecha Leo
thing1

I'm certain for all except Mecha Leo that it's not their favourite sport.

So it's possible to assume the murderer meant American football.

EDIT - Then again that brings up the previous point mentioned my leggy that there could be Americans who call it football making it harder to determine.

Well, my favorite sport is tennis. Although I do root for the packers, I'm not a huge fan of football.


I honestly don't know what to do here. I think I'll wait until another user makes a vote and then I'll decide.

MLB= Major League Baseball
Also, basketball is my favorite anyways. So ha.
It's definitely not leggy, he's obsessed with baseball, unless somehow his love for football ballooned recently.

I'll be straightforward. I have a feeling we won't be getting very far with our suspicions on who's more likely the murderer. Therefore I'll go with my guts on this one, plain and simple.

Vote: deg2000

deg2000 : Feel free to defend yourself. Or don't. It's up to you.

mlb789 :

... I'm just going to answer that question with silence. And also the statement "really".

I laughed for a solid minute when you even suggested that. Guffaw my good sir.

-----

I'll wait to hear deg's defense before I vote for him. I don't want to randomly lynch people, although if he even likes football, he's a prime suspect, as I'd judge him to have 6/10 activity, and he has used the Minecraft server before

I really have nothing to say except I hate american football but European football I like 6/10 activity when the heck did I earn that from. I literially have no way to defend myself as I haven't looked in this thread for a while I mean I never check in on it. SO feel free to vote for me.