Dang. The doctor. That's another special role down. I suppose it could have been worse and that the sheriff got taken out. At least we still have that one.

And to the accusations- Mega and silver, you both are making it hard for us not to choose either of you. Silver is making some convincing arguments against Mega which is getting me to believe he may indeed be part of the Mafia, but Mega is making good points as well. Not only that, Silver is adamant about taking down Mega. Hardcore. I'm not too sure if he is on to something or if he is really part of the Mafia and thinks Mega is a threat. I think I'll wait a little bit longer to see which direction this situation is going before putting in my vote.

silverthundr : That post was directed to Super... Not you... Just clearing that up in this post.

Oh noes, the doctor has fallen. Nobody can be revived now.

I suppose I should go with MEGAREVOLUTION1 since he's been acting strange lately.

MegaRevolution1 : Ahh. Well, then, I still don't see why you'd need to mention not accusing supersonic. As far as I can tell, the only thing she did was accuse you. It seems you are getting a bit jumpy, but it might just be me.

I am going to be talking a bit more this round than I have previously. I was going to just stay under the radar, but I've got enough Mafia found out to call them out and still have time to dig up the third. That is, if I don't die in the day round. But, either way, let's get this voting going. I'd like to see how this turns out.

silverthundr - 3
MegaRevolution1 - 4

Looks like it's just gonna be between these two. I'll update once we have at least 50% of players accusing.

I hate to turn this into a Spartacus situation, but here it goes: I am the sheriff. I haven't checked up on silverthundr, but I can tell you that MegaRevolution1 is a bystander. Now while that is very suspicious of silverthundr to impersonate me, I understand that a bystander or other benign entity might be just as likely as a mafia member to assert that he or she is the sheriff, in order to spice things up. Either way, silverthundr, mission accomplished. You have my attention.

Anyways... I accuse geeogree of being a mafia member.

Hold on now! Silver and Morsalbus are claiming to be the sheriff?!? Well this sucks. How to point the gun at the right head --other than at my own?

Going with SilvrThundr if you ask me. I just do not think he seems like he should be trusted. He looks like he could kill if you ask me. He also posts in this thread a lot which means he is probably watching it so he can see who should pick off. He knows too much, he is probably a godfather.

Ooh dearie. This will be fun.

You realize that the fastest way to prove a role is to kill the person.

I'd say that Morsalbus is a thug, except that is not the thugs job. I like how he took my little noticed call out of geeo to use as proof. As it is, killing geeogree will prove nothing, as we BOTH agree he is Mafia. HOWEVER, we disagree on Mega's role, so we COULD kill Mega. As it is, I think the best move this round would be either.

1. Kill MegaRevolution1 (already accused)
2. Kill Morsalbus (accusation here)
3. Kill me (I'm not going to pull a Snowdeath, plus I already accused geeogree, so...)

Either of these things occurring will prove my claim, but I put them in order of my preference. As it is, it doesn't matter. If you kill Mega, it prove my claim. If you kill Morsalbus, it proves my claim. Of course, I don't know what his role is, and I'm not wasting my night round, in the instance I survive, checking him. It'll likely give me Not Mafia, simply meaning Godfather. If I die, it again proves my claim. Place your bets, townies.

silverthundr : I didn't "notice your little call out of geeo" at all, I'm sorry to say. I just honestly don't have any concrete evidence of your position yet, so I chose someone who I already knew was mafia, and would be reasonable for people to vote for. The fact that roles were assigned according to activity for the most part would make geeo, a very long runner on this site, a reasonable suspect for even confused bystanders. I accused him and not you because I am conservative like that, and here you are pointing back at me.

EDIT: And I also, from an outsider's perspective, would doubt either one of the two of us is the godfather, as it's such a large risk.

It's time for "Post Dissection Time" with your host, silverthundr!


"I didn't "notice your little call out of geeo" at all, I'm sorry to say."

So it's just a coincidence. Right.

"I just honestly don't have any concrete evidence of your position yet, so I chose someone who I already knew was mafia, and would be reasonable for people to vote for."

The only way to have concrete evidence is for a) The person to die, b) Sheriff to discover Mafia, or c) Mafia and Godfather know each other.

"The fact that roles were assigned according to activity..."

TIMEOUT! I guess you people STILL don't realize, but
ROLES ARE ASSIGNED AT RANDOM!!!

"...or the most part would make geeo, a very long runner on this site, a reasonable suspect for even confused bystanders. "

Well, really, Bystanders can, and will, vote for anyone for just about any reason. I mean, UserMike got killed due to a random accusation, a bandwagon, and bad logic all around.

"I accused him and not you because I am conservative like that..."

Eh? What?

"...and here you are pointing back at me."

Well, of course I am. If I just let you stand there claiming Sheriff after me, and then accuse someone WE'VE BOTH ACCUSED, nothing will be proven by that. I'm just accusing the people that will give the "confused bystanders" the truth, instead of just cause more confusion. And if I have to die for it, so be it. If it looks like geeo will beat me into the final voting, I may pull a Snowdeath, because I'd like to accomplish something. Go martyrdom.

Sorry Silverthundr, I guess my point was, since I don't really suspect you of anything other than mischief, I'd rather we actually vote for someone I know to be mafia than kill off you or me or Mega just for information.

But see, the issue here is who is ACTUALLY the Sheriff. We need to find this out. And really, if I was Mafia, why would I accuse 2 Mafia (you can say he is a Bystander all you want, but MegaRevolution is Mafia according to my investigation.) AND tell people to off me? If this were the case, the worst outcome is that I accuse 2 Bystanders and get killed as.. what, a Bystander? Why would a Bystander do this? So I'd be Mafia? Well, as I've said, I'll die to prove it. So, let's go.

I stand by the fact that I am the Sheriff. If I'm lyin', I'm dyin'.

2 sheriffs? One has to be lying.... so I'm going to accuse Morsalbus and silverthunr because one of them is lying about their role.

geeogree : Right. We're definitely going to listen to the one person everyone agrees is mafia. We get it, you want to save your own skin.

silverthundr : Seriously though, I didn't think of this earlier, but you made it sound like me accusing geeo makes me more suspicious, but if he really is mafia, why would I accuse him? And what reason would I have as a mafia member to put myself out in the open like this? To save Mega and put a nail into geeo's coffin? If I was the godfather, or any mafia member, I would not take this risk. The only reasons I might take the risk of doing this is 1. Because I am the sheriff, or 2. Because I'm getting very bored with my status as a bystander. I suspect one of us is posting like this because of reason 1, and the other because of reason 2. In any case I would truly hate to let geeogree get away while we bicker about who the sheriff is.

Oh, I bet leggy is laughing at this. Or at least will be when he checks up again. I know I sure am.

Anyways, yes, killing a definite Mafiosi is appealing, but so is killing a definite Mafiosi AND proving one's role. So, as I said, I'd prefer to see MegaRevolution1 take the bullet today. Or the noose. Or a guillotine... Hey leggy! Do we have a guillotine? Can we use that today?

Anyways, back on topic...

Worst case scenario : I fit into your second possibility, kill off Mega, an innocent bystander. The Mafia kills another Bystander in the Night. I die next round due to lying, and so we are down 3 Bystanders. A fourth dies in the night, and we are at 4:8.

I may be a gambler, but that makes no sense.

Best case scenario : I am the actual Sheriff. Mega dies in the day round, as a Mafia. A person dies in the night (It may be me, although I still have Mafia potential, so it'll likely be a random Bystander), I find a third Mafia over night, and put out the 3 Mafia and you are left as being the Godfather.

I'll say it again : Place your bets, townies.

silverthundr :

I was actually laughing the entire time, so you get a Leggy Point for reading my mind.

Anyway... update

People who have accused - Who was accused

silverthundr - MegaRevolution1, geeogree, Morsalbus (MAX)
MegaRevolution1 - silverthundr
supersonic1998 - MegaRevolution1, silverthundr
AuraBlaze - MegaRevolution1
big fat cat - silverthundr
pacman1755 - MegaRevolution1
Morsalbus - geeogree
billythekidmonster - silverthundr
geeogree - morsalbus, silverthundr


Cyro Xero - No accusation, but a post

16 players, 9 have accused, 1 stayed silent

I can continue the game at midnight my time, but I'll give these guys time to make an accusation

tabbikatt13
NovemberJoy
the_casualty
Someone70
Reptile
Juliet

Time to kill Morsalbus. silverthundr is right and your story isn't adding up.

Sorry bro.

MORSALBUS. Why he is lieing un doubt ably. Two people claiming to be a sheriff that is not good stuff. I hope that neither of you are because if the sheriff dies then the mafia are sure to win.

I also convict PACMAN1755. He convicted me and this is a way of saying that nothing goes un noticed. I also think that he is just a little to shady for my liking.

Forgot to leave the tally

silverthundr - 5
MegaRevolution1 - 4
Morsalbus - 4
geeogree - 2
pacman1755 - 1