I agree, as long as we don't take that to mean that we should suspect people because of their silence. That's a combination of me thinking it would be logically invalid, and me not wanting to be killed just because I hold off a bit on posting. xD

Well, I've always played Mafia different then you guys.

Here's an example of how the game should be played (in my opinion).

Yeah the real way is what cassu's example is or somewhat related to that. Saying something suspicious is pretty much key to playing the game I guess.

yeah, different people have different ways to play a game like this...

and there is also activity level to consider.... some people have loads of time to post and read and such and others only have time to accuse/vote.

Well I really do not care how we play to be honest. I think that it is fine how it is now. Though some people do play it a little wrong.

I think the way we play it is best for THIS SITE.

I dumbed down the rules because a lot of people wouldn't really get everything and would get frusturated.

The way we play it is simple and allows for this fastened game.

legacyme3 : That is what I was saying by some people play it a little wrong. There are a lot of kids that are on this site and also playing the game. They would not understand it if we had a huge set of rules, and then it would turn to crap.

Spot on with your answer.

Hey, leggy, does this break for 9/11 mean no update tonight, or is it your excuse for no update yesterday? Because you update at midnight, tonight's update would be 9/12, so....

Last night, the mafia had a good sleep. And it's understandable, as noelia, the Doctor took the big sleep.

It'd be slightly more humorous if it weren't for the fact that the bystanders were slipping behind.

LIST O PLAYERS! (4:12 with one thug)

1. tabikatt13
2. NovemberJoy
3. the_casualty
5. Someone70
6. pacman1755
7. geeogree
9. AuraBlaze
10. MegaRevolution1
11. billythekidmonster
12. Reptile
13. silverthundr
15. supersonic1998
18. Morsalbus
19. big fat cat
20. Cyro Xero
21. Juliet

Roles left

Bystander (9)
Mafia (3)
Godfather
Thug (1)
Insomniac
Sheriff

Huh. Noelia was the doctor. Well, I guess my guess was wrong.

ANYWAYS, I am sick of this. So, I guess I'll just say it. I am the Sheriff
If you vote to kill me, you will know I was right, although I'd like to avoid that.

I found 2 Mafia so far. 3 nights, 2 Mafia, good record for me.

Anyways, I accuse MegaRevolution1 and geeogree as being Mafia.
MegaRevolution1 : Yes, I lied to you about my role. You lied too. Well, not the first time.

So, there we go. Questions, Comments, Concerns?

EDIT: geeogree accusation withdrawn for tactical purposes. HOWEVER, I still say that he is Mafia.

"You lied too. Well, not the first time."
Note- The first time was when I said I was on the bystanders side, second time (the lie) was the mafia side.
I am truly not that enemy here. I am on the side of the bystanders. Choose to not believe my words, you will only be standing in the pit of flames you walked oh so eagerly into.
Also, out of everyone, you seem to be causing the bystanders to be losing the most people. And I'm not sure about Geeo, but you are trying to get rid of another bystander, which is me. You claim to be the leader of our team, but it is a team you are killing with minimum effort. You show a reckless behavior, but what you are truly hiding is the fact that YOU, among all the members here, are one of the leading Mafia members.
Therefore, I accuse SilverThundR.

MegaRevolution1 : That sounds like a load of crap. Since the last day round, I had my suspicions about you for trying to fling me under the bus for just making a simple statement. Hence, I accuse you, MEGAREVOLUTION1. Now, you are even more suspicious. To say, "I'm on the bystanders side" then say, "I'm mafia" is ludicrous. That raises my suspicion meter from 4 to 5. You just seem like you are telling us lies trying to cover you butt and stay alive. 5 to 6. Accusing silverthundr has also made my meter go up. 6 to 7.

MegaRevolution1 : You know what I mean by "the first time". You also had bad luck then attempting to masquerade as the Doctor, whom you (The Mafia) just killed.

Anyways, your biggest mistake was killing Sun right off. I wasn't too surprised to get the response that you were, indeed, a Mafia Member. My check on geeogree had to do with the fact that,

1. As far as I could tell, you didn't try to cover it up to him, and
2. I already had suspicions from his play style.

And I was only a bit surprised to get the "MAFIA" response on him.

Oh, and I won't reveal who my other investigation was of, as "Not Mafia" is not a conclusive answer, with the Godfather and all

Well, let's hope that, surviving the day round, I continue my streak for the third Mafiosi.

And what good is a suspicion if it is only made because you were accused by decoding a simple message into what could or could not be a hint? While you said that statement, dragoon was killed, and turned up to be a mafia member. A low one, but still a mafia member.
4 to 5, While I tell the truth of being on the Bystanders side, what makes Silver not suspicious for claiming to be the Sheriff? A high leveled Bystander role that is unlikely to achieve?
5 to 6, if I wanted to lie to save myself, I would. If I wanted to bend logic to save myself, I would. I have no intentions of lying or bending logic.
6 to 7, it's an accusation based on a very high level of logical thinking. Accusing me for accusing him could well over mean that you too are on his side and areagainst me to save him from being the first mafia member to be eliminated.
But, however, I will not accuse you for being mafia, being it'd be a waste of an accusation.

How does Drag00n fit into this? This is about me saying "dont ya think its weird that no one started to think snow till me n dragoon said it" and you accusing me just for the fact of saying that. Silver is suspicious. I just suspect you more than him. He's at 5 on the suspicious meter. You and he both have that....mafia feel. you more than him. And, ahem, dont you think you are bending logic now? turning my own words against me? i think you are and i dont wanna fall for your crap-trap. you have a weird way of bending logic and twisting and contorting words to make the person who originally said those words feel confuzzeled, or make them seem like the bad guy. You have twisted and contorted MY words, making me confuzzled, but I chopped through all the twistedness. My accusation list reads: MEGAREVOLUTION1 and SILVERTHUNDR.

Just keeping track of the accusations as they happen.

silverthundr - 2
MegaRevolution1 - 2

I'm only going to accuse MEGAREVOLUTION1 this time. But know this, if mega does not happen to be a mafia member, I will be pointing the gun at Silver next time.

I'm going to dissect your post now.

"And what good is a suspicion if it is only made because you were accused by decoding a simple message into what could or could not be a hint?"

But this is exactly how you are supposed to play Mafia. You are supposed to pick apart what people say until you find something suspicious.

"While you said that statement, dragoon was killed, and turned up to be a mafia member. A low one, but still a mafia member."

While I said made what statement? I don't understand this bit at all. Except the fact that you guys ended up killing your thug. Bad luck on your part, yet again.


"4 to 5, While I tell the truth of being on the Bystanders side, what makes Silver not suspicious for claiming to be the Sheriff? A high leveled Bystander role that is unlikely to achieve?"

Exactly. It does make me suspicious, and I'd be disappointed if I only got accusations/votes from you and geeo. You people should not take everything at face value. Like someone claiming to be on the Bystanders side, or being a regular Bystander. It's the easiest role to claim to be, and so the most common role claimed by Mafiosi. Or by anyone with a special role that is afraid of dying.

"5 to 6, if I wanted to lie to save myself, I would. If I wanted to bend logic to save myself, I would. I have no intentions of lying or bending logic."

But you did. You lied to me at least twice, but that's irrelevant. The relevant point is that you are bending logic to save yourself. Self-contradiction does not help you one bit.

"6 to 7, it's an accusation based on a very high level of logical thinking. Accusing me for accusing him could well over mean that you too are on his side and areagainst me to save him from being the first mafia member to be eliminated."(sic)

Eh? Because I used logic, that makes me suspicious? I don't get that part, but whatever. Also, nice defensive stance there. Very basic Mafia strategy.

"But, however, I will not accuse you for being mafia, being it'd be a waste of an accusation."

Well, right off, this is wrong, because

"Therefore, I accuse SilverThundR."

Was your post before that. You already accused me, accusing me again would do nothing anyway.

Also, I'd like to say, before we get into voting, and the Night round, that my death leads me to martyrdom and proves my statements. Geeo, unknown Mafiosi, Godfather, I'd like you to think about that before killing me in the Night round. All you will do is cause your own downfall.

And Mega, don't feel bad about being left out, I just think you will be the first Mafia voted off the island, and so won't get a vote in the Night Round.

(dangit, I've missed a lot)

Reading up, ^ sounds very suspicious as does mega.

My vote goes to silverthundr .

See! I was innocent!!!