So I usually watch toonami and ever sense Space dandy, SAO( Favorite show of all time), and Attack on titan left. The anime they usually play just isn't appealing to me. I mean I don't know why but I just cant get into those ones. So I was wondering if their is something you have to recommend me.

Oh man, where to begin...

--Full Metal Alchemist (or FMA Brotherhood) Most would say brotherhood is better, since it's the same story, but differs completely in the second half of the series.

--Death Note is an amazing show. Many an anime fan will rave over this one.

--Cowboy Bepop is amazing, and was made by the same people who later did Space Dandy.

--One Punch Man is currently airing on Toonami. I've never seen it myself, but a lot of people on the board seem to recommend it.

--Mirai Nikki (or Future Diary in English) is an awesome show with an extremely unique concept. A must see.

--K is a really cool anime, though it is really short. A very unique concept as well.

--Durarara! is a really cool show, with A Lot of interesting characters. They currently just finished the second season with 25 episodes in the first, and about 36 in the second. I definitely recommend it.

--Darker Than Black is one of my personal favorites. The main character is a boss (but not in a OP way) and the "powers" in the show are really unique. 

--Akame Ga Kill is one I think you would really like considering the ones you listed. Despite how it comes off at first, it can get really dark at times.

--Parasyte: The Maxim is another personal favorite. Toonami actually still airs it, but it's currently halfway or so through the series.

--Fate/Zero is an awesome anime, and easily the best of the entire Fate/  franchise. It's also the prequel, so you're starting at the very beginning of everything.

--Samurai Champloo is amazing, and is basically a lot like Cowboy Bepop with samurai way back when in Japan. One of the characters is exactly like Spike from CB lol.

--The Legend of the Legendary Heroes is another personal favorite, though the anime never actually finishes the story. It gets just far enough to really leave you hanging lol.

--Baccano! is an epic anime with some really cool characters. The story line is really jumbled up though in terms of what it's showing you and when it happened, so you have to be really sharp to catch when everything happened in order. 

--Black Butler is a really cool anime. The big finale of the show was especially awesome. I think you'd like it.

--Psycho-Pass is another great anime, though it can be extremely gory at times. People's bodies explode in pretty much every episode, and it doesn't censor hardly anything at all.

--Jormungand is an anime set in a very realistic world. Nothing supernatural here, just straight action like real people even though it's not exactly "realistic" if you know what I mean. It's about as real as an anime will depict the world lol. 

--Black Lagoon is the exact same concept as the previously mentioned title, just in a different world with different characters.

--Claymore is full of action, but it only has one season that doesn't wrap anything up. It's about a chick who hunts demons who can disguise themselves as humans. Using their own power against them, she can sniff them out and take them on.

I hope this list satisfies. If not, there's quite a bit more I could recommend depending on your preference

Liar Game. It's quite interesting. I also recommend Re Zero, Prison School, any Fate anime (like Fate/Stay Night), Code Geass, My hero academia, Is it wrong to pick up girls in a dungeon? and Your lie in april. Check those out if you can.

Hm... You enjoyed SAO? Then would you consider watching .hack//Sign? It's also about an online world... (not going to go into spoilers). And no, not all of the .hacks are made equal (.hack//Roots kind of drags on for a while... oO;; so I would recommend the movie .hack//G.U. Trilogy for that one instead).

I would recommend most of the anime that Mynamescox44 already listed, but since I don't see many animated films on there, I guess I'll go with recommending the films by Studio Ghibli, such as Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind or one of the films by Satoshi Kon called Millennium Actress. If you don't want to watch any of these, feel free to let me know and I'll recommend some others.

If you enjoy spellcasting and don't mind inconsistent animation, then Ojamajo Doremi may be for you. If you prefer something adorable and fluffy, then Fushigiboshi no Futagohime can work.