Starship one, by Atari, is one of the first non bat and ball arcade games by the company. ?
As such, it has good graphics for the time, so I have given it a high score
The sound is an improvement on the bleeps of pong, but not by much. ?So the score is low, to reflect this.
The game has that, 'just one more try' feel. ?So I consider it reasonably addictive. ?This also, is why I give it a middle area depth rate.
There is not really a story, just shoot everything, and avoid crashing into other ships, and the planets.
As it's a reasonably easy game, it gets a low score from me.

The Game itself, shows the interest in the original Star Trek, that some of the early Atari programmers had. ?With all but one of the ships you shoot at, having a reference to it in some way. ?
There is a ship that looks like a United Federation of Planets scout. ?(The one with the Enterprise type saucer, and 'fin' to the warp engine.)
The other ship looks like a Klingon D7 Battle Cruiser, but with round warp nacelles, not rectangular.
The 'Space Monster' is based on the title craft, from the episode 'The Doomsday Machine'.
The fourth ship is a generic 'flying saucer' shape.?

I see that you tried to explain why you rated each category how you did, but you didn't really explain it very well. All you did was give one example. For example, when talking about the graphics, talk about which parts of the games looked good and which didn't.

tgags123 :  Ok.   So I didn't review it that well.  But I think it was better than my first one.  Don't want to get into a Augment with you on here, over my reviews.  So if you have any criticisms, let me know by PM.  
One thing I do notice, is that for some reason, there are a number of '?' in the post.  I didn't put them there.