Personally, I think the original intention was to just not shame people, because shame tends to lead to more destructive problems instead of helping fix the problem (if it actually is one) and makes things worse in the long run.
I don't think the original intention of fat acceptance was to glorify obesity. I really don't. I think the original intent was to make people who are overweight not be so ashamed of their body that they do nothing to help themselves. I don't know about you, but if I am ashamed of something, I tend to try to hide it, not bring it out where potentially more people could see it, make fun of me and make me feel awful about it, even if doing so might help me fix what I'm ashamed about.
This is why so many overweight people won't go to fitness classes, the gym, or even fun things like zumba classes or what not. They are SO SURE that people are going to laugh or shame them for not being perfectly fit that they get discouraged before they even go...so they simply don't. It's a destructive cycle, but one that is very hard to break. Take it from someone who's been there.
I'm not sure how far things have gone now, but I believe that the original intent was to take away this shame so people who are unhealthy and overweight could do something about it without being stigmatized into immobility, which worsens the problem. After all, wouldn't you rather receive encouragement, making you feel good about yourself and energizing you into making yourself feel even BETTER about yourself? I know I would. The thing is is that so much backlash (at least early on, when I paid attention to this sort of deali-o) happened that people responded by getting more and more radical, trying to get themselves heard. It's gotten out of control now, I think.
I do agree with one thing that gets said a lot, though. You don't have to be thin to be healthy. You can carry too much weight and be HEALTHY. I look at some weight lifter and runner women (who, as far as I know, don't use steroids) who are clearly overweight, but they are strong, they are fit, they can run for MILES without being out of breath or they can lift incredible amounts of weight and be steady...I see health. THeir bodies may carry too much fat, but sometimes that's just because of how a person's body make up is. So that much, I do agree with. The fat-shaming aspect of saying 'everyone who is overweight is unhealthy' simply isn't true, and neither is the reverse. Everyone who is thin is not healthy. There's more to it than that. *sigh*
Personally, I think the original intention was to just not shame people, because shame tends to lead to more destructive problems instead of helping fix the problem (if it actually is one) and makes things worse in the long run.
I don't think the original intention of fat acceptance was to glorify obesity. I really don't. I think the original intent was to make people who are overweight not be so ashamed of their body that they do nothing to help themselves. I don't know about you, but if I am ashamed of something, I tend to try to hide it, not bring it out where potentially more people could see it, make fun of me and make me feel awful about it, even if doing so might help me fix what I'm ashamed about.
This is why so many overweight people won't go to fitness classes, the gym, or even fun things like zumba classes or what not. They are SO SURE that people are going to laugh or shame them for not being perfectly fit that they get discouraged before they even go...so they simply don't. It's a destructive cycle, but one that is very hard to break. Take it from someone who's been there.
I'm not sure how far things have gone now, but I believe that the original intent was to take away this shame so people who are unhealthy and overweight could do something about it without being stigmatized into immobility, which worsens the problem. After all, wouldn't you rather receive encouragement, making you feel good about yourself and energizing you into making yourself feel even BETTER about yourself? I know I would. The thing is is that so much backlash (at least early on, when I paid attention to this sort of deali-o) happened that people responded by getting more and more radical, trying to get themselves heard. It's gotten out of control now, I think.
I do agree with one thing that gets said a lot, though. You don't have to be thin to be healthy. You can carry too much weight and be HEALTHY. I look at some weight lifter and runner women (who, as far as I know, don't use steroids) who are clearly overweight, but they are strong, they are fit, they can run for MILES without being out of breath or they can lift incredible amounts of weight and be steady...I see health. THeir bodies may carry too much fat, but sometimes that's just because of how a person's body make up is. So that much, I do agree with. The fat-shaming aspect of saying 'everyone who is overweight is unhealthy' simply isn't true, and neither is the reverse. Everyone who is thin is not healthy. There's more to it than that. *sigh*