There aren't any real leads here. So I think that a no kill is the best option here.

What's behind door #1?

A vote for No Kill, that's what.

Guess I'm going to have to vote No Kill for now. There's nothing to really go on.

So we're going passive first day then? I guess the chance of lynching someone useful IS pretty daunting. No kill sounds good.

Hello Mafia players, I haven't posted yet so far so I want to say hello to you all!

That being said, I have read all the posts and since things just have started, I guess a No Kill  is what I'm going for as well, chances are big we might screw up and kill somebody innocent of course.

So guys... I feel like it's really worth mentioning here that it's a double kill day? Doesn't matter if we all vote no kill, if someone votes at last minute and EVERYONE else votes no kill, someone is still dying. This a very dangerous situation for everyone here, and quite frankly I don't think we can afford to not lynch someone. It allows any dangerous roles to just stay passive and attack during the night, it is literally sabotaging us.

Frodlex : Who do you suggest we vote for then?

Frodlex : We have nothing to go on, though. Are we sure we want to randomly vote for someone? Or maybe someone who is town wants to take the fall for us?

Just a reminder that the day round ends in about 12 hours.

Vote No Kill
Been reading posts here and there and I can't really judge anyone just yet since everyone besides Frodlex is saying just about the same thing.
In my opinion I feel like mafia if he isn't mafia he will die soon since how well he knows the roles.

Frodlex :
That was my first thought as well, but really any mafia member who waits until the last second and then tries to lynch an innocent will be taking a pretty serious risk to their own livelihood. I'm planning on staying on and monitoring for kill votes and I'm ready to quickly change my vote if someone tries that, but even if we don't act fast enough to kill the voter, we will suspect them, and most likely lynch them next round. On the other hand, if we pretend it's reasonable at this stage to lynch without evidence then we risk killing an important town role. So strangely, it seems to me that it's in both the mafia's and the town's best interest to keep the No Kill votes going strong.

For trolling purposes...
I might as well get lynched since I'm in the hospital.

I change my vote to Snowdeath.

Sorry for late reply, just got off work, I'm going to go ahead and vote for SNOWDEATH , it's my only logical choice now, keeps me from getting voted tied second, so protection is always your first choice in Mafia games, right? Anyway we need to start talking strategy fast, town; It gives Mafia free reign to kill us if we don't.

Snowdeath : Also recommend not trolling mafia games, but leggyist?

If Snowdeath is suddenly voting for herself she may be The Fool.

I like where this discussion is going, so I'm postponing the end of the day round for 24 hours.

Surgiac :
That may be true, and if it's true, we all lose nothing by letting her kill herself. Personally, I suspect she's simply not a very exciting role and wants to get things over with. Whether she's town, mafia, or third party, there's no reason to keep her from dying since she won't be any good to any of us. Frodlex has voted for her as well out of "self-preservation" but the fact of the matter is that it would still only take one vote for him to die as well (being a doube death day), so I'm not sure I see the point there.

Ultimately there's not much changed here at all, and it's still in both town's and Mafia's best interest to stay on the no kill, as I explained earlier.

Side note: Part of the reason I think Snow is not the Fool, and indeed that there is no Fool this round, is because I'd like to think Leggy isn't stupid enough to start a mafia game with a fool and then have a day round where they can easily lynch themselves on the first day.

Morsalbus :

Side note response: Possibly, but Leggy is also twisted & may do exactly that.

For those who's curious, my role is bystander.

Surgiac : Well, unless I'm mistaken doesn't the top two votes win? No Kill included as first place and then Snow as second? Even if someone voted for me, Snow would win second place with 2 votes to my 1. Should be safe to assure my safety, I guess I need to thoroughly check the rule thread, but I'm not sure if it mentions double kill day rules or not. That aside, at the very least it gets things going, although it is easily possible she is in fact a leggyist/ fool trying to lynch herself, I'm not terribly worried about the risk.

Snowdeath : Sorry to say, but claiming to have any role at all basically has no value to you in your position, unless you were to claim leggyist or fool which would end up a terrible, because A: We might try and call a bluff; Or B: You'll have revealed your role and therefore the nessecary tactic to compromise you. That aside, from what I understand, you want out of the game anyway. So eh.