Forum Links
Scholastic Has Gone Too Far
A rant against the 39 Clues
A rant against the 39 Clues
Related Threads
Coming Soon
Thread Information
Thread Actions
Thread Closed
New Thread
New Poll
Order
Scholastic Has Gone Too Far
09-10-14 04:00 PM
zanderlex is Offline
| ID: 1077560 | 687 Words
| ID: 1077560 | 687 Words
zanderlex
dark mode
dark mode
Level: 263
POSTS: 6960/28313
POST EXP: 1930156
LVL EXP: 296148698
CP: 156522.2
VIZ: 12362679
POSTS: 6960/28313
POST EXP: 1930156
LVL EXP: 296148698
CP: 156522.2
VIZ: 12362679
Likes: 0 Dislikes: 0
Now don't get me wrong, The 39 Clues is my most favorite book series of all time. I have read 19 of the main books, and just today bought the 21st book so I can get it autographed at the book festival next week. I like the series so much that my 3 favorite books in general of all time are all from this series. However, even though I love this series so much, I think that the publishers are taking it too far. The first series, which was pure epic and only had 10 books finished back in 2010. Everybody was so happy to see how it would end, but then Scholastic announced that there would be an even better 2nd series. The first series was very long, and ended up finishing with 11 books, a few side books, and 7 ebooks, but everybody was super happy that the series would continue. They were right though, the 2nd series was even better, they were able to condense all the action and suspense of the 10 books from series 1 into 6 books, which is still quite long. March 2013 came along and everybody was hyped about the final book because there was much more drama and suspense in that one book than the entire first series, but then Scholastic made it seem like even more stuff could happen by adding a third series. Instead of being all, woooooh, like I did after the 1st series, I was meh this time. I told myself this that it couldnt get any better. I was wrong though, the first book of the 4 book series 3 was even better than any of the others in my opinion, but it's as if you could feel pain in the book. As a fan, you know what the characters have gone through and you just want it to end. I read books 1 and 2, and I bought book 4 today in the hopes it would be the all powerful final book that I would get autographed and keep forever, and then on the last page of the book, there's a design. Each book of course, has it's own cover design, and each series has it's own logo style, so when I first saw that design, I knew that there was going to be a 4th book before I even checked online. It was a new logo design I have never seen before, and when I finally checked online, it was confirmed that there's a 4th AND FINAL series coming out next year. If this was a series like The hardy Boys, where each book is a random story with no relationship to the other, I would be fine, but this is not like that. Each book, even books from the other series, are a direct contininuation, and when you do that, you have to end at some point, and I feel that they should have already ended. Again, don't get me wrong, it's not like they ran out of ideas or their ideas are getting stale, it's just that they put in so many ideas and after each one they have a nice way to finish it off, but theydon't, they keep going on and on, making it even more dramatic for the people reading because they have more things to worry about. Sure, the 2nd series was great, but when the 1st series ended, I thought I was out oft he clear, that everything bad had happened already, and then when the next series was announced, you already start thinking about all the bad things that can happen, even months before the book is released. After the 1st series ended, it got to the point where good things don't happen anymore, the only excitement from the later series is the main characters stopping the bad stuff from happening in the coolest of ways, but other than that, more and more people die who you would have thought were safe, and everybody is torn apart. There are other fans of the books out there, right? What do you think of this? However, even though I love this series so much, I think that the publishers are taking it too far. The first series, which was pure epic and only had 10 books finished back in 2010. Everybody was so happy to see how it would end, but then Scholastic announced that there would be an even better 2nd series. The first series was very long, and ended up finishing with 11 books, a few side books, and 7 ebooks, but everybody was super happy that the series would continue. They were right though, the 2nd series was even better, they were able to condense all the action and suspense of the 10 books from series 1 into 6 books, which is still quite long. March 2013 came along and everybody was hyped about the final book because there was much more drama and suspense in that one book than the entire first series, but then Scholastic made it seem like even more stuff could happen by adding a third series. Instead of being all, woooooh, like I did after the 1st series, I was meh this time. I told myself this that it couldnt get any better. I was wrong though, the first book of the 4 book series 3 was even better than any of the others in my opinion, but it's as if you could feel pain in the book. As a fan, you know what the characters have gone through and you just want it to end. I read books 1 and 2, and I bought book 4 today in the hopes it would be the all powerful final book that I would get autographed and keep forever, and then on the last page of the book, there's a design. Each book of course, has it's own cover design, and each series has it's own logo style, so when I first saw that design, I knew that there was going to be a 4th book before I even checked online. It was a new logo design I have never seen before, and when I finally checked online, it was confirmed that there's a 4th AND FINAL series coming out next year. If this was a series like The hardy Boys, where each book is a random story with no relationship to the other, I would be fine, but this is not like that. Each book, even books from the other series, are a direct contininuation, and when you do that, you have to end at some point, and I feel that they should have already ended. Again, don't get me wrong, it's not like they ran out of ideas or their ideas are getting stale, it's just that they put in so many ideas and after each one they have a nice way to finish it off, but theydon't, they keep going on and on, making it even more dramatic for the people reading because they have more things to worry about. Sure, the 2nd series was great, but when the 1st series ended, I thought I was out oft he clear, that everything bad had happened already, and then when the next series was announced, you already start thinking about all the bad things that can happen, even months before the book is released. After the 1st series ended, it got to the point where good things don't happen anymore, the only excitement from the later series is the main characters stopping the bad stuff from happening in the coolest of ways, but other than that, more and more people die who you would have thought were safe, and everybody is torn apart. There are other fans of the books out there, right? What do you think of this? |
Vizzed Elite
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-25-13
Location: Inaba
Last Post: 2 days
Last Active: 14 hours
Sergei's Mustache |
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-25-13
Location: Inaba
Last Post: 2 days
Last Active: 14 hours
09-11-14 04:21 PM
EideticMemory is Offline
| ID: 1077908 | 91 Words
| ID: 1077908 | 91 Words
EideticMemory
Level: 138
POSTS: 3828/6326
POST EXP: 427597
LVL EXP: 30885207
CP: 26372.5
VIZ: 1209954
POSTS: 3828/6326
POST EXP: 427597
LVL EXP: 30885207
CP: 26372.5
VIZ: 1209954
Likes: 0 Dislikes: 0
I understand your pain. They're trying to squeeze every penny out of the series, and for the readers it's terrible.
And while I can't think of any particular book series where this happened, I know it happens all the time with movies and TV shows. It's not unnatural to see one book to take up multiple movies these days, when it would have done just fine as a single release. Several TV shows get uninspired or change so much in later seasons that I just don't like watching them anymore. =/ And while I can't think of any particular book series where this happened, I know it happens all the time with movies and TV shows. It's not unnatural to see one book to take up multiple movies these days, when it would have done just fine as a single release. Several TV shows get uninspired or change so much in later seasons that I just don't like watching them anymore. =/ |
Vizzed Elite
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 12-30-13
Location: North Carolina, USA
Last Post: 182 days
Last Active: 182 days
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 12-30-13
Location: North Carolina, USA
Last Post: 182 days
Last Active: 182 days
09-12-14 01:25 AM
steel_attacker is Offline
| ID: 1078030 | 76 Words
| ID: 1078030 | 76 Words
steel_attacker
Level: 69
POSTS: 952/1281
POST EXP: 43985
LVL EXP: 2854015
CP: 2459.4
VIZ: 74704
POSTS: 952/1281
POST EXP: 43985
LVL EXP: 2854015
CP: 2459.4
VIZ: 74704
Likes: 0 Dislikes: 0
So I'm not the only one... Yeah, I got excited with the series, too. But after buying two books (One from 39 Clues and one from Cahills v.s Vespers), I did the maths and found out I'd be spending a fortune on these books. So I just stopped. How about they use the same ideas (e.g. The family branches) and make a new series with different characters? Would you read that? Something old becoming new again. So I'm not the only one... Yeah, I got excited with the series, too. But after buying two books (One from 39 Clues and one from Cahills v.s Vespers), I did the maths and found out I'd be spending a fortune on these books. So I just stopped. How about they use the same ideas (e.g. The family branches) and make a new series with different characters? Would you read that? Something old becoming new again. |
Trusted Member
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-15-13
Location: In the moment
Last Post: 3052 days
Last Active: 827 days
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-15-13
Location: In the moment
Last Post: 3052 days
Last Active: 827 days
09-12-14 08:30 AM
zanderlex is Offline
| ID: 1078088 | 56 Words
| ID: 1078088 | 56 Words
zanderlex
dark mode
dark mode
Level: 263
POSTS: 6991/28313
POST EXP: 1930156
LVL EXP: 296148698
CP: 156522.2
VIZ: 12362679
POSTS: 6991/28313
POST EXP: 1930156
LVL EXP: 296148698
CP: 156522.2
VIZ: 12362679
Likes: 0 Dislikes: 0
steel_attacker : They did that too! Aside from the main official series of now 21+ books, they have also released 15 different sidebooks and ebook series. And the only book I ever paid for was the 21st 2 days ago, which I thought was the final. I borrowed all the others from libraries for 6 years now. steel_attacker : They did that too! Aside from the main official series of now 21+ books, they have also released 15 different sidebooks and ebook series. And the only book I ever paid for was the 21st 2 days ago, which I thought was the final. I borrowed all the others from libraries for 6 years now. |
Vizzed Elite
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-25-13
Location: Inaba
Last Post: 2 days
Last Active: 14 hours
Sergei's Mustache |
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-25-13
Location: Inaba
Last Post: 2 days
Last Active: 14 hours
09-12-14 07:37 PM
steel_attacker is Offline
| ID: 1078275 | 43 Words
| ID: 1078275 | 43 Words
steel_attacker
Level: 69
POSTS: 954/1281
POST EXP: 43985
LVL EXP: 2854015
CP: 2459.4
VIZ: 74704
POSTS: 954/1281
POST EXP: 43985
LVL EXP: 2854015
CP: 2459.4
VIZ: 74704
Likes: 0 Dislikes: 0
zanderlex : Correction: They did backstories for the characters. What I meant was maybe after a few years someone else had to undertake some kind of impossible task that had something to do with the Cahill family. Sidebooks? Meh. I like Percy Jackson more... zanderlex : Correction: They did backstories for the characters. What I meant was maybe after a few years someone else had to undertake some kind of impossible task that had something to do with the Cahill family. Sidebooks? Meh. I like Percy Jackson more... |
Trusted Member
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-15-13
Location: In the moment
Last Post: 3052 days
Last Active: 827 days
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-15-13
Location: In the moment
Last Post: 3052 days
Last Active: 827 days
09-13-14 09:44 AM
zanderlex is Offline
| ID: 1078396 | 100 Words
| ID: 1078396 | 100 Words
zanderlex
dark mode
dark mode
Level: 263
POSTS: 7014/28313
POST EXP: 1930156
LVL EXP: 296148698
CP: 156522.2
VIZ: 12362679
POSTS: 7014/28313
POST EXP: 1930156
LVL EXP: 296148698
CP: 156522.2
VIZ: 12362679
Likes: 0 Dislikes: 0
steel_attacker : Sidebooks? There's 15 sidebooks. Most of the sidebooks have nothing to do with the same characters from the series, but new characters from many years ago. http://the39clues.scholastic.com/cahillfiles That link goes to the Cahill Files, a series of 5 books. The first 2 books involve some of the characters when they were young, but the last 3 are all from the 1700's and 1800's. Now that there's going to be a 4th series, that nobody knows how many books there will be, or how many years it will last, there's going to be an opportunity to write even more sidebooks. steel_attacker : Sidebooks? There's 15 sidebooks. Most of the sidebooks have nothing to do with the same characters from the series, but new characters from many years ago. http://the39clues.scholastic.com/cahillfiles That link goes to the Cahill Files, a series of 5 books. The first 2 books involve some of the characters when they were young, but the last 3 are all from the 1700's and 1800's. Now that there's going to be a 4th series, that nobody knows how many books there will be, or how many years it will last, there's going to be an opportunity to write even more sidebooks. |
Vizzed Elite
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-25-13
Location: Inaba
Last Post: 2 days
Last Active: 14 hours
Sergei's Mustache |
Affected by 'Laziness Syndrome'
Registered: 09-25-13
Location: Inaba
Last Post: 2 days
Last Active: 14 hours
Links
Page Comments
This page has no comments