Register  |  Login Retro Game Room  |  Board  |  Downloads  |  Memberlist  |  Video Game Room Staff  |  About Us  |  Help Center  
  Views: 1,471,795,439     05-30-15 09:29 AM  

Are hack roms legal?




Thread closed

Are hack roms legal?
Add to favorites | "RSS" Feed | Next newer thread | Next older thread

Posted on 03-22-10 03:46 PM metal572 is Offline     Post: 329 words - (ID: 157647) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
metal572
Level: 64


POSTS: 169/1320
POST EXP: 64648
LVL EXP: 2209566
CP: 56.2
VIZ: 10337
Ok well i have heard a bunch of different things about this and was wondering if they are legal or not. I think they might not be because the hacks are based of a rom which is illegal to have., so wouldnt a hack be illegal then because it needs the rom? people say 24hr rule and backup rule but my understanding is the 24 hr rule isnt true and as far as roms go http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ROM_image look at the lagal status part in fact ill just copy and paste it here
"In some countries, it is legal for an individual to personally make backup copies of a game they own. Individuals may make backup copies for various reasons, perhaps as insurance against losing the game or as redundancy in the event that the original game's medium becomes unreadable. See the section on ROMs and Preservation.

However, in the U.S. it has been illegal since 1983 for a user to create their own backups of video game ROMs onto other cartridges. This was decided in the court case of Atari v. JS&A. JS&A manufactured a "game backup" device that allowed users to dump their Atari ROMs onto a blank cartridge. JS&A argued that the archival rule allowed for this. The court disagreed, noting that ROM media was not subject to the same volatility as magnetic media (for which the law was created). Thus, not being so relatively vulnerable, ROMs were not applicable under section 17 USC 117(a)(2).

Some games companies, such as Nintendo, print warnings inside their game manuals that they do not allow users to make backup or archival copies. Whether or not these warnings in this specific form can be considered valid contracts is legally questionable. For an overview of relevant issues, see user agreement (EULA), shrink wrap contract, clickwrap, Fair Use, Fair Dealing and DMCA."
so what do u all think?

EDIT: And also what about translated roms? isn't that still nintendo's game just a different language? (last edited by metal572 on 03-22-10 03:55 PM)
I am vengeance, I am the night, I, AM, BATMAN!!!
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 08-06-09
Last Post: 768 days
Last Active: 384 days

Sponsor

Posted on 03-22-10 03:52 PM bigNATE is Offline     Post: 58 words - (ID: 157650) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
bigNATE
Level: 102


POSTS: 984/3937
POST EXP: 201769
LVL EXP: 10963621
CP: 108.3
VIZ: 16539
Well, from what I understand, since once you have patched the game, it's an altered ROM and therefore not the original game anymore, I don't think there's a problem. You are no longer playing Nintendo's game, you're playing the hacker's, you know? Besides, the only thing I've heard against hacks is that you're not supposed to sell them.

King Yoshi
Vizzed's resident Jesus Freak
Looks like Teach just got tenure!
Summoner of Slowbro
Fifth Place in February '11 VCS
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 01-06-10
From: Thulcandra
Last Post: 124 days
Last Active: 117 days

Posted on 03-22-10 03:54 PM metal572 is Offline     Post: 12 words - (ID: 157652) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
metal572
Level: 64


POSTS: 170/1320
POST EXP: 64648
LVL EXP: 2209566
CP: 56.2
VIZ: 10337
I am editing my post to also include talk about translated roms.
I am vengeance, I am the night, I, AM, BATMAN!!!
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 08-06-09
Last Post: 768 days
Last Active: 384 days

Posted on 03-23-10 12:03 AM Mattman324 is Offline     Post: 58 words - (ID: 157857) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
Mattman324
Level: 23


POSTS: 96/125
POST EXP: 10223
LVL EXP: 61507
CP: 3.0
VIZ: 3112
As long as full credit is given to the origanal creator, and the person who is giving out the game does NOT make a profit out of it, it is entirely legal.

Heck, Roms by themselves are legal as long as they aren't sold for cash. (I looked this stuff up, it's a good thing to do occasionally.)

Nidorino

Member
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Member
Since: 02-08-10
Last Post: 1873 days
Last Active: 1865 days

Posted on 08-08-10 06:34 AM joshman700 is Offline     Post: 15 words - (ID: 219961) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
joshman700
Level: 14


POSTS: 14/42
POST EXP: 906
LVL EXP: 11419
CP: 1.9
VIZ: 6572
yes but if you have got the game i think its alright to download it

Pidgey

Member
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Member
Since: 08-04-10
From: leister
Last Post: 1738 days
Last Active: 1235 days

Posted on 08-08-10 08:46 AM Videogamegod is Offline     Post: 21 words - (ID: 219991) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
Videogamegod
Level: 73


POSTS: 105/1850
POST EXP: 38432
LVL EXP: 3349636
CP: 3.0
VIZ: 34792
They are legal. Basically, if you give full credit to the creator, and you don't make money off it, you're fine

Sledge Brother
The Master at Video Games :D
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Member
Since: 07-23-10
Last Post: 1652 days
Last Active: 1566 days

Posted on 08-10-10 02:08 AM Merrik is Offline     Post: 33 words - (ID: 220875) - Post Rating: 0 - Report Abuse | Link
Merrik
Level: 34


POSTS: 208/308
POST EXP: 14236
LVL EXP: 229876
CP: 19.0
VIZ: 17229
I don't think so because it's not a copy of the original anymore and it belongs to the hacker, so not completely. I believe they are illegal to sell in real life though.

Primeape
Returning Member
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Trusted
Since: 06-16-10
From: New Mexico
Last Post: 1639 days
Last Active: 146 days
Add to favorites | "RSS" Feed | Next newer thread | Next older thread
Vizzed Board - Trash Can - Pokemon
Are hack roms legal?
| | Thread closed

  Site Info  Sponsor  
  Vizzed.com © was created, designed, coded by & is property of:
David Auchampach
All Rights Reserved 2002 - 2015
Powered By: Vizzed Board, Acmlm Board and Adeon Dev.
Affiliates: get-your-rom.com - mybiblegames.com -  


Search Engine Keywords:
are pokemon rom hacks legal (1),  legit pokemon rom hacks (1),  Are recoded roms legal (1),  

Page rendered in 0.159 seconds.