I apologize if the vote counts are a smidge off (there are a lot of you, and you all posted a lot.)

-----
Gingercream1 - 12
No Kill - 13
paper luigi - 1
No Vote/Blank - 2

You chose NO KILL
-----

The players gathered at the campfire. Darkness was beginning to fall, and there were 28 uneasy souls huddled around a fire made for only 6.

Cramped, and growing displeased with the general odor of everyone else, they decided to push Gingercream1 out of the fire. Somehow, shoving a person out of the small circle made it feel much more roomy.

"We're not gonna kill you, but because you are so suspicious, you don't get any fire tonight." said one of the players who voted against her.

She pouted in the corner, and drew one of her art thingies.

"So we're going with no kill, right?"

"Yeah."

"Sounds like a plan to me."

"OK, then. No kill it is, we'll just keep an eye on everyone tonight."

This was cool, I guess. Then, as the players got ready to head for bed, something miraculous happened.

A potato fell from the sky.

It was almost as if God himself had dropped this potato, which looked quite moldy, and not at all edible. But it also looked rock solid.

The potato fell a while longer, until it achieved terminal velocity. Then it conked Gingercream1 on the head. Upon impact, the noise was heard all around. Everyone rushed to the potato. And to Ginger too, I guess.

They saw that Gingercream1 was dead. And beside her cold dead corpse was a list, with some writing on it. It had a few names on it! Curse the lack of light! This could have been the chance to expose who the mafia was!

Because Gingercream1 was the Godfather.

And before anyone gets any ideas...

As one of the players reached for the paper, to save it for the morning, the potato grew legs, walked over to the paper, opened it's mouth (?) and ate the paper. It then farted out a second piece of paper.

This paper had gold lettering on it, so it could be seen in the dark.

"You guys just unlocked the potato rule. Let's see if anyone can guess what it is."

Then the potato vanished, seemingly returning to the heavens from whence it came.

Truly, this was an event worthy of confusion and scorn. The Mafia lost a member somehow. What on earth was going on?

As they lay in their beds, waiting for morning, night descended for real, and left them time to determine their next course of action.

LIST O PLAYERS
A user of this :
Popeye116 :
earthwarrior :
yoshirulez! :
pokemon x :
patar4097 :
mvhupsel :
mrfe :
deg2000 :
mlb789 :
styrofoamboots :
Snowdeath :
Boxia :
supernerd117 :
thing1 :
Frodlex :
kirbmanboggle :
zanderlex :
megamanmaniac :
juuldude :
paper luigi :
Blubcreator :
Gamin'Gal :
Zlinqx :
darthyoda :
Pokefreak219 :
GameBoy1023 :

It is now a night round. (Ginger, if you want an explanation, I can tell you privately, so long as you do not tell any of the other players.)

If you have a night action, send in your night round role asap.

Well I would have seriously thought she could cheat death. But by a potato how does this island work!? and I feel somewhat sad that she died

 Well then... a normal game of mafia just became very... VERY confusing. I dont understand what just happened... but at least i was right with my suspicions But i need to know one thing...

sonicmcmuffin :

Is this someone you suspected as mafia? ;P

People are confused about the potato, and more are going to be confused, so let me just say this:
It pooped out a piece of paper with golden letters after falling from the sky and killing GingerCream1 at maximum velocity. What is so strange about that?

Pokefreak219 :

He has lost the right to speak.

For one, he is dead.

And for two, he refused to elaborate on this list when asked. So I honestly assume he was bluffing.

legacyme3 : We need a person who can speak to the dead Because that will just bug me for the rest of the game.

Pokefreak219 :

Well you don't. Even if you did, the dead people wouldn't talk back.

Unless they break the #1 rule of Mafia. In which case, I would be very disappointed in them.

I have a problem with this kill.
I have no problem with it being the godfather, mind you. That part is fantastic.
It's the fact I know it came from a meta.
This is terrible.
Also, another godfather. That's my guess for the potato. Either that or it has something to do with no killing and mafia or town lynches.

Also, I'm going to post here...

But I've been made aware of metagaming, with photographic proof of said meta-gaming.

All I'm going to say is "Rule 9".

I know the argument for PMs not being public, but you know what the rule means.

I'm disappointed in anyone who has shared proof of their role via PM.

You are violating the spirit of the game, and it makes me feel FAR FAR less of you as people.

legacyme3 : wooooooooot finnally ginger died i don't meen to sound mean twas acting suspicous

kirbmanboggle : Oh screw you. it's not my fault people cheat.

Gingercream1 : hey hey hey! no need to be a jerk

I've done a small amount of investigation, and have decided to (for now) allow this game to continue.

This is subject to change at any time. If I for some reason, close this game, I will invite all players back. (If this happens, the roles would be reassigned)

kirbmanboggle : What did you expect her response to be?

legacyme3 : I regret to say I was among those people. I apologize for overlooking this rule, and beg for the forgiveness of Leggy. I will avoid doing so in the future.

supernerd117 : You seem to have bad luck with Mafia. You revealed who the Mafia members were last game, and took part in the metagaming this round. Furthermore, you admitted it to everyone rather than just PMing him or something. So yeah...

earthwarrior : I agree, in addition it only requires suuuuuuuper basic knowledge of HTML or CSS to edit that as well. Simply click 'Reply to PM', edit what you want to edit, then click 'Preview Message' to have a legit new role (at least in the eyes of the viewer).

megamanmaniac : It was my intent to bring this out into the open. I did not want there to be any dark secrets around me. I didn't pay enough attention to the rules, and I would rather it be public information than be a secret that would burden me, and not serve as a lesson.

Alright, after a lengthy investigation, I've decided on the following.

1) This round is going to be completely restarted. Gingercream1 and sonicmcmuffin will be brought back to life, the roles will be redone, so you will get a new role PM from me. The role sheet will also be completely different, so just because there was a certain role this game doesn't mean the new game will have it.

2) The player guilty of the biggest offense, Boxia, is until further notice, banned from Mafia, and any other Innocent Town games, for betraying the Mafia (he was Mafia himself) and ultimately destroying what should have been an enjoyable game.

3) mrfe, and the various members of his group (sans Boxia) will be alleviated of all infractions against Rule 9, as it was my fault for not being more clear about the rule. I figured it was more obvious, but I need to remember, not everyone is me.

4) This is the last warning for a lot of players. If you break any rule, especially rule 9 or the unwritten rule about playing the role you are given (do I really need to put that on the rules page?)

So this is my apology to ALL of the players who played. This round has been a bust, and most of you didn't even realize it. Anyone summoned below is invited back. If you do not want to play (which I will totally understand, let me know when I send you your new PM. If any players with power roles refuse to play, I will send their roles to bystanders.)

Also, EideticMemory has offered to join our field to get back up to 29, and I am only too happy to accept. I hope you all welcome him, and return to the game. This new game will start in 24 hours, and like each other day, will have a 72 hour night round to start the game. Again, I apologize for the inconvenience.

A user of this :
Popeye116 :
earthwarrior :
yoshirulez! :
pokemon x :
Gingercream1 :
patar4097 :
mvhupsel :
mrfe :
deg2000 :
mlb789 :
styrofoamboots :
Snowdeath :
supernerd117 :
thing1 :
Frodlex :
kirbmanboggle :
zanderlex :
megamanmaniac :
juuldude :
paper luigi :
Blubcreator :
sonicmcmuffin :
Gamin'Gal :
Zlinqx :
darthyoda :
Pokefreak219 :
GameBoy1023 :
EideticMemory :