So basically answer the question

For me Yes I have put out Milk and Cookies when I was young for Santa

I stopped doing this at 10 because I found out the secret and was very upset.

I never believed in St. Nick, so I've never done this tradition. I actually did this last year for an experiment, I camped out in the living room, and saw it coming: My mother ate all the cookies and threw out the milk.

PixelBrick :


Awww dude I am sorry to hear that this happened.

Actually You probably laughed when your mom came and did that,I know I would of.

What age were you smart enough to know that it was your mom

I stopped putting milk and cookies out for "Santa" when I was 12 years old because that year I found out from my parents that Santa isn't real.

PacmanandMariofan :

How did you find this big secret out.

Did they come out and tell you because they thought you were old enough or did you find out.

knockout575 : They told me about it because they thought I was old enough.

PacmanandMariofan :


Was it your Mom or your Dad eating all the cookies and Milk that you set out for "Santa" ?

I never put out cookies and milk for the Santa. I don't even remember believing him. But the reason is that I never actually knew much about Santa. I didn't even know his name when I might of believed him.

sedo45 :

I see what you are saying.

You never actually learned about him but believed in him.

but if you knew his name you would of believed in him more.

I actually never put cookies and milk out for santa...i dont really see why..since i dont believe in santa anymore.

supercool22 :

Well when I believed in him I did because I thought I wouldn't get presents if i didn't.
and well who doesn't like milk and cookies.

PacmanandMariofan : He isn't real? :'(
Well, i stopped when I was 11 because, as pac, I found out

Never did, I had believed in Santa at one point, but stopping when I was about 8.

Never. I never much fancied The Fat Man. I'm 14 now so it would be pretty ridiculous if I still did. I don't think I ever bought the story of a magical overweight white man coming all the way around the world  to deliver a name brand toy to a little boys house. I may have done it once when I was eight or something, but just to make my mom happy. The fact that he wasn't real never really bothered me. I was probably still immature and selfish back then. So the only thing that mattered was getting something.

Well for me and my siblings we never really believed in him though it was fun making ideas up on how he could of come into our house without use knowing.  My brother had a make shift room near the back door so Santa couldn't of come through there,  We had no fire place so he couldn't come through there.  So my siblings and I came to the conclusion if there was such a magical person he would either have the help of our parents through the front door or have magic to come through the tv....  Our parents gave up trying to convince me by around age 4 lol!  My siblings and I were too smart for them!

Now we did give out cookies for our parents!  We thought they needed them to set things up for Christmas.  Also we wanted cookies!  So we would fool with our parents and say we wanted to set cookies and eggnog out for Santa!  Worked every year~!

Now with my niece she's 6 and still believes in Santa.  When she moved here she asked how Santa came to our house without a fire place so I told her we let him in through the front door.   She doesn't have the benefit of having other kids to pick apart the Santa story.  But we get to make cookies now!  We are doing that today!

LCRain :

I have never thought of ways he could get into my house because i was like 8,but then again I never had siblings to assist me in this reasoning.If i did have siblings I probably would of stopped believing in Santa if I had siblings.


kidcop :

Yeah when I was young and found out that Santa was not
 the one that delivered the presents to my house, I was not upset because I just wanted presents and also I was immature like you said.


soldierboi159 :

I bet you hid downstairs and waited all night to see if he'd come didn't you?

This was never a tradition here but I was aware of it from American movies. The closest one I can think of  a tradition like that here was that kids after they had compiled their wish list to Santa they would leave it on their window, preferably outside so the elves would get it and take it to Santa. Ofcource they would since they would be always watching you in secret. It was a magical moment when it was gone in the morning.

At age 17. This year. Today. Didn't have any cookies to put out =(

My cousin and I used to put out cookies and milk for Santa when we were younger. After we found out the truth (my family told us), we just stopped at age 11. I wasn't upset about it at all though.