geeogree
Level: 223


POSTS: 17770/20832
POST EXP: 1256880
LVL EXP: 166249863
CP: 2316.6
VIZ: 800461

I have a question for everyone....

Do you find yourself more likely to read and/or reply to a thread based on who started it?


I'll put myself out as an example because well, most everyone knows me. And then the other person I'll use is a random "new person" who very few people know or have ever spoken to.


If we both made the exact same thread at the exact same time (but the thread creation creates 2 alternate universes).... which thread would get more activity? Mine or the new persons? This is assuming the exact same thread was made but I made mine in an alternate universe from the one the "new person" made theirs. Hopefully that made sense.


My points is:

Do you think there is a bias towards "established" or "popular" members threads over new people's threads?

Specter
Elara: "You are, of course, the undisputed master of the ban hammer. You're like Thor for Vizzed."
Affected by 'Carpal Tunnel Syndrome'

Position: Global
Role: CP & Viz Manager

Since: 01-03-05
From: Alberta, Canada
Last Post: 12 hours
Last Active: 1 hour

tabbikatt13
Level: 64


POSTS: 760/1904
POST EXP: 54861
LVL EXP: 2098541
CP: 0.0
VIZ: 54775

Not for me, personally. It doesn't matter to me who started the thread. If I feel like I can give a good response, I will reply to it. Simple as that. 

Onix
WINNER of September 2011 VCS!
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Trusted
Since: 08-20-11
From: Oregon
Last Post: 517 days
Last Active: 438 days

AuraBlaze
Level: 80


POSTS: 1079/2916
POST EXP: 208471
LVL EXP: 4580488
CP: 72.1
VIZ: 61532

I feel that such thread favoritism may be playing out in the fact that I am responding to this in the first place --despite the fact that there is no duplicate made by another person. I think there could be other factors that play into this. Aren't the more well-known members those that have proven to be respectful of others? Not 100% of the time, but usually I assume. Newer members tend to make duplicates both intentionally and unintentionally. I admit that I would be a bit biased here and would gravitate to the thread made by the veteran member. However, I could address the other person's thread first if it happens to have the discussion furthered by other members already. So for me, there is a possibility but it is not guaranteed.

Marowak
Beautiful Letdown
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 01-23-11
Last Post: 1 day
Last Active: 12 hours

geeogree
Level: 223


POSTS: 17777/20832
POST EXP: 1256880
LVL EXP: 166249863
CP: 2316.6
VIZ: 800461

AuraBlaze : that is a fair point. A more established member should be making good thread regardless...

but that doesn't immediately mean that new members make bad ones.

Specter
Elara: "You are, of course, the undisputed master of the ban hammer. You're like Thor for Vizzed."
Affected by 'Carpal Tunnel Syndrome'

Position: Global
Role: CP & Viz Manager

Since: 01-03-05
From: Alberta, Canada
Last Post: 12 hours
Last Active: 1 hour

AuraBlaze
Level: 80


POSTS: 1092/2916
POST EXP: 208471
LVL EXP: 4580488
CP: 72.1
VIZ: 61532

That is quite true, but with what I have seen coming from newbies in the past few months I have become biased to think that newbies will not make great threads. Even I made a duplicate when I was a newbie --though it was only a duplicate by technicality.

Marowak
Beautiful Letdown
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 01-23-11
Last Post: 1 day
Last Active: 12 hours

coda57
Level: 22


POSTS: 75/158
POST EXP: 8941
LVL EXP: 56472
CP: 20.5
VIZ: 9497

No not really, if the thread sounds like its interesting then ill read it. But i suppose people may favorite a thread because the person posted, either because its a good post or their funny or their friends.

Jigglypuff

Member
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Member
Since: 03-02-11
Last Post: 412 days
Last Active: 259 days

alexanyways
Level: 143


POSTS: 7896/10284
POST EXP: 411113
LVL EXP: 35816343
CP: 2711.4
VIZ: 16540

No, I post in a thread based on how good of a question was asked/ how useful it was.

Crawl
King of all Magikarps
VIZZEDS GREATEST ZELDA FAN.
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Local
Since: 02-24-10
From: Dog Fort
Last Post: 1 day
Last Active: 7 hours

UserMike
Level: 96


POSTS: 3659/4420
POST EXP: 165850
LVL EXP: 8791368
CP: 1411.4
VIZ: 72448

While it does sort of of seem that way I usually look into threads that interest me and if the discussion or topic appeals to me regardless of who made it. Though I do tend to see threads by "user" of those I have seen more often across the message board rather than those who more recently joined.

Saber Tooth
Playstation Gamer
☜☆☞Gamer Underground☜☆☞ ♪ ♫
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 12-05-10
From: CA,USA
Last Post: 42 days
Last Active: 1 day

Hoochman
Level: 66


POSTS: 1424/1669
POST EXP: 63636
LVL EXP: 2340396
CP: 70.5
VIZ: 110851

I don't hold a lot favoritism based on user popularity when responding to a thread. A popular persons thread might be the 1st thread I notice though. It really depends on the the thread issue and what terms I'm on with the guy who made the thread. So if its a controversial issue and the user who brought it up doesn't get along with me, I'll probably stay out.

Kung Lao

Member
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Member
Since: 02-25-10
From: Minnesota
Last Post: 44 days
Last Active: 1 hour

noelia
Level: 134


POSTS: 7629/8748
POST EXP: 304654
LVL EXP: 27873360
CP: 1924.8
VIZ: 431177

I remember that people didn't reply often to my threads and polls, when I was new here. But when I became a trusted member, things has changed. So I guess there is some thread favoritism sometimes.
As for me, I try to be unbiased, but sometimes I might be more willing to reply to some threads than others.

1st Place in the July 2010 VCS Competition!

Affected by Tomb Raider syndrome
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 03-15-10
From: Croft Manor
Last Post: 460 days
Last Active: 460 days

rcarter2
Level: 109


POSTS: 571/6285
POST EXP: 507077
LVL EXP: 13628794
CP: 16177.5
VIZ: 750559

When I am checking out the new posts, I typically look at the title of the thread. If it sounds interesting, I'll enter and then see who made it. But I do think that the bias has to exist. I have seen in the past threads with very similar topics, and one gets an astounding higher amount of posts than the other. Usually, the one that has more posts belong to a user who's name I recognize. But I like to see what other sides of the same topic there are, which gives me more to post.

Star Mario
Dominating RGR Competition Hall of Fame Table!
Affected by 'Carpal Tunnel Syndrome'

Position: Site Staff
Role: Game Reviewer

Since: 05-01-11
From: Kansas
Last Post: 13 hours
Last Active: 20 min.

NotJon
Level: 93


POSTS: 2829/3496
POST EXP: 183935
LVL EXP: 7801842
CP: 54.2
VIZ: 126099

I'd like to think that I don't partake in favoring one thread over another just because of the member who started the thread. However, I usually feel a little obligation to comment on a thread from a user that I know more personally than a complete stranger. Additionally, all threads that I feel like I have a suitable response to will get a post from me, regardless of its creator.

---

(last edited by NotJon on 09-08-11 02:44 PM)

Sea Snake
More Not than the average Jon
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 06-24-09
From: Paterson, NJ
Last Post: 135 days
Last Active: 101 days

billythekidmonster
Level: 103


POSTS: 3352/4999
POST EXP: 206752
LVL EXP: 11212980
CP: 81.6
VIZ: 90514

No I used to avoid threads by certain people but they are gone now so it is not a big deal. I usually just post regardless of whos it is. I really don't care. I do not think that it really makes a difference.

Star Luigi
3rd place in the August 2011 VCS! I got 3rd place in the October 2010 VCS! 3DS friend code 1762-2680-4239 pm me yours
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Member
Since: 08-16-10
Last Post: 515 days
Last Active: 237 days

Elara
Level: 100


POSTS: 2384/3252
POST EXP: 267953
LVL EXP: 10297404
CP: 348.0
VIZ: 146247

Much like rcarter, I look at the thread title more than I do who made it. I will look at the name once I am in the thread.

Vitreous
Dark Elf Goddess
Penguins Fan
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 12-08-04
Last Post: 4 days
Last Active: 14 hours

thenumberone
Level: 102


POSTS: 1205/5275
POST EXP: 258089
LVL EXP: 10758145
CP: 2106.6
VIZ: 131569

I avoid some peoples threads but i dont beeline for the well known users threads,i check what catches my interest.certainly there is some bias though,if i make a thread now it gets way more attention than it used to.

in my end is my begining
Affected by 'Carpal Tunnel Syndrome'

Position: Elite
Since: 03-22-11
From: Scotland(the cold,wet place)
Last Post: 20 hours
Last Active: 5 hours

Natas
Level: 58


POSTS: 1309/1471
POST EXP: 102948
LVL EXP: 1561608
CP: 153.4
VIZ: 33707

Well, knowing you are the popular one instead of the "new person" depending if the "new person" had a name for himself/herself. You will get the most replies since people wants to be known for posting in a popular thread. Not talking about the ones who commented in this thread, because I agree with them myself. I don't care if the person is popular or not. It's more about the quality and how good the question is that draws my attention to that thread. I like looking at threads with the quality, because it gives me a chance to give a decent reply instead of some question I don't understand or  make sense.

Beamos
The nice guy of Vizzed
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Elite
Since: 04-13-11
From: Monroe, La
Last Post: 88 days
Last Active: 86 days

geeogree
Level: 223


POSTS: 17849/20832
POST EXP: 1256880
LVL EXP: 166249863
CP: 2316.6
VIZ: 800461

I find the responses of this thread interesting because my perception of what people have done and their perception seem to differ greatly.

However, I think a big factor that I can't fix would be experience level of an established "popular" member versus the newbie.... the experienced members are more likely to make good quality and/or interesting threads to the board since that person has a better idea of what the board will and won't respond well to.

Specter
Elara: "You are, of course, the undisputed master of the ban hammer. You're like Thor for Vizzed."
Affected by 'Carpal Tunnel Syndrome'

Position: Global
Role: CP & Viz Manager

Since: 01-03-05
From: Alberta, Canada
Last Post: 12 hours
Last Active: 1 hour

DARKANINE
Level: 65


POSTS: 924/1771
POST EXP: 43082
LVL EXP: 2234927
CP: 106.3
VIZ: 2239

i post in it for what its about if it interest or concerns me

Ptooie
Great scott! I'm great!
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Trusted
Since: 12-01-10
From: Raleigh
Last Post: 25 days
Last Active: 1 day

cooleo
Level: 51


POSTS: 835/1093
POST EXP: 16066
LVL EXP: 1012156
CP: 17.0
VIZ: 42625

no i don't reply to the thread just because who made it

Red Stalfos
CHRISTIAN FOR LYFE
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position: Trusted
Since: 03-26-11
Last Post: 161 days
Last Active: 9 days

legacyme3
Level: 190


POSTS: 7477/21106
POST EXP: 1235676
LVL EXP: 95866319
CP: 10882.5
VIZ: 2936

I have to say that there IS a thread favoritism.

I will post in a thread if it interests me.

Generally, the well known members DO a better job selling me on the thread than a newbie member or someone not that well known.

Generally, the more well known members are more well known for their post quality, therefor, it is likely that if I click on a well known member's thread, I will be more likely to stumble onto a good thread.

So yeah, I'd say there is such a thing as thread favoritism, but keep in mind this is much like real life.

If William Shatner gives the president a document that is identical to the one that Joe Everyman gives him, then it wouldn't be a stretch to say the president would be more interested in Mr. Shatners proposal, even if it is EXACTLY the same.

Another example.

Your boss has recently hired a well known financial aid to the company. You yourself work in that department. However, you are new to the job, and you are not as well regarded as this new guy. The new guy and you agree on everything, and you both present the same identical net gain to the company. However, he will get the recognition because he is the well known guy.

It's not all bad though, every company, site, and group have those guys, but they also have the other guys, the unsung heros that do more than people think they do.

Dewgong
#Goodbye
Affected by 'Laziness'

Position:
Since: 09-14-10
Last Post: 32 days
Last Active: 31 days